Bama/LSU rematch

Corley1011

Corley1011

Hail State!
Forum Member
Dec 13, 2006
11,744
62
48
40
Madison, MS
Am I the only one that thinks Bama should NOT get a rematch???


Bama had their shot at home and lost...


That would mean LSU would have to beat Bama twice and Bama would only have to win once...


It would also mean LSU would have to win out... including a game with #8 Arkansas... and win the SECCG just to get to the NC game... and all Bama would have to do is beat MSU, Ga Sou, and Aub...


Keep in mind both Ok St and Stanford would have to lose...
 
Skipper

Skipper

BITCH!!
Forum Member
Feb 19, 2003
4,733
44
48
Knoxville
Corley1011 said:
Am I the only one that thinks Bama should NOT get a rematch???


Bama had their shot at home and lost...


That would mean LSU would have to beat Bama twice and Bama would only have to win once...


It would also mean LSU would have to win out... including a game with #8 Arkansas... and win the SECCG just to get to the NC game... and all Bama would have to do is beat MSU, Ga Sou, and Aub...


Keep in mind both Ok St and Stanford would have to lose...
Click to expand...

No, I agree 100%. Bama loses at home so no way they should get a rematch. I am sorry to the Bama nation, but win at home. Rematch always favors the team that lost, and LSU should not have to win again.
 
jr11

jr11

08-18-05
Forum Member
Jul 19, 2002
5,830
29
0
114
HELL
Agree with everyone above, no way. You lost at HOME, enough said and LSU should not have to beat you 2x's to win NC, plus I truly dont believe you should have a chance at the current NC with the system in place IF you dont win your own conference.

Any way you look at I am hoping for a mess every which way. I am hoping they all lose, LSU OkST and Stanford or all win out to create a true shitstorm.
 
Skipper

Skipper

BITCH!!
Forum Member
Feb 19, 2003
4,733
44
48
Knoxville
jr11 said:
Agree with everyone above, no way. You lost at HOME, enough said and LSU should not have to beat you 2x's to win NC, plus I truly dont believe you should have a chance at the current NC with the system in place IF you dont win your own conference.

Any way you look at I am hoping for a mess every which way. I am hoping they all lose, LSU OkST and Stanford or all win out to create a true shitstorm.
Click to expand...

:0074
 
gjn23

gjn23

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 20, 2002
9,319
45
48
55
So. Cal
so if stan looses to ore (could happen)
and
osu looses to ok (could happen)

who "deserves" a shot at the title game???

boise? (are they really better than any of the teams listed below)
bama? (lost to lsu)
okla? (who lost to tt)
stan? (who lost to ore)
ore? (didnt the already lose to lsu)

lsu has to play SOMEBODY.....if stan AND ok st lose, why wouldnt there be a rematch??
 
I

in the black

Registered User
Forum Member
Dec 27, 2004
1,333
7
0
B'ham,AL.
If Bama gets a rematch they would be getting rewarded for losing a home game.LSU will have to win out and play an extra game-at a neutral site- in the SEC Championship while Bama sits home,after playing MSU,Ga Sou.,and AU,and waits for the BCS Championship Game?

Is that happens all hell will break loose I would imagine.And if that is the scenario that would play out then LSU would have been better off losing Saturday.Of course everybody knows anybody other than Bama,Notre Dame,and a few others would have dropped further than Bama did after this loss.LSU wouldn't have been 3rd the day after losing this game I don't believe?
 
Cie

Cie

Registered
Forum Member
Apr 30, 2003
22,391
253
0
New Orleans
gjn23 said:
so if stan looses to ore (could happen)
and
osu looses to ok (could happen)

who "deserves" a shot at the title game???

boise? (are they really better than any of the teams listed below)
bama? (lost to lsu)
okla? (who lost to tt)
stan? (who lost to ore)
ore? (didnt the already lose to lsu)

lsu has to play SOMEBODY.....if stan AND ok st lose, why wouldnt there be a rematch??
Click to expand...

Because Bama's lone loss was to LSU at home, while Oregon's lone loss, also to LSU, took place on a neutral field, which was 75% LSU fans from what I've heard. I would vote Oreg #2 if Oreg, LSU and Bama win out and Stan and Okie St lose.
 
LonghornMM

LonghornMM

Registered User
Forum Member
Oct 30, 2003
4,819
523
113
Deer Park, TX
IMO the only way that Bama could be considered for a rematch is if besides LSU, there are no undefeated teams left. Otherwise, no!
 
Skipper

Skipper

BITCH!!
Forum Member
Feb 19, 2003
4,733
44
48
Knoxville
If Georgia wins the SEC East and is competitive with LSU, then Boise might get a shot.

Boise better be pulling for UGA the rest of the way
 
Cie

Cie

Registered
Forum Member
Apr 30, 2003
22,391
253
0
New Orleans
LonghornMM said:
IMO the only way that Bama could be considered for a rematch is if besides LSU, there are no undefeated teams left. Otherwise, no!
Click to expand...


IMO, a 1 loss Okie St, Okie, Stan, Oregon and Bama all would deserve a shot ahead of an undefeated Boise.

If Stan or Okie St remain undefeated I give them the nod over bama. If Okie St loses on the road to a ranked foe, then I give Okie St the nod. If stan loses to Oreg and Oreg goes undefeated rest of the way, I gove the nod to Oreg
 
Cie

Cie

Registered
Forum Member
Apr 30, 2003
22,391
253
0
New Orleans
Skipper said:
If Georgia wins the SEC East and is competitive with LSU, then Boise might get a shot.

Boise better be pulling for UGA the rest of the way
Click to expand...

Exactly. This is Boise's main hope imo. UGA to play LSU tight or defeat LSU. If LSU makes it to the SEC title game, that is.....
 
F

forthetide2

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 21, 2011
412
7
0
Alabama
Only scenario that could possibly justify a rematch..

stanford, ok. state lose

LSU loses to Arkansas..which leaves a 3-way tie in the SEC West. Bama would probably move ahead of LSU in the BCS if they lose to Arkansas. The tie breeaker in the SEC is highest BCS ranking goes to championship game. That would put Bama in the SEC championship game. If that takes place and Bama wins out that is the only way it would happen imo.

Arkansas would also have to win out in conference play for that 3-way tie.
 
Last edited:
the addict

the addict

BI-WINNING
Forum Member
Oct 9, 2009
13,034
116
0
40
PA proud
bamas loses again and end of discussion :scared


ya, not gonna happen but that would really end this discussion thread




boise vs lsu in the title game if they both win out.....:0008


i would love it....and be on boise plus the points
 
Corley1011

Corley1011

Hail State!
Forum Member
Dec 13, 2006
11,744
62
48
40
Madison, MS
Cie Grant said:
Because Bama's lone loss was to LSU at home, while Oregon's lone loss, also to LSU, took place on a neutral field, which was 75% LSU fans from what I've heard. I would vote Oreg #2 if Oreg, LSU and Bama win out and Stan and Okie St lose.
Click to expand...




Only thing I see wrong with that argument is that you can't use the neutral field with LSU fans dominating the attendance angle... It will be 10x worse with the NC game being in Nola
 
the addict

the addict

BI-WINNING
Forum Member
Oct 9, 2009
13,034
116
0
40
PA proud
i just dont think two teams from the same confrence should be in title game...


if we are going to totally disregard every other team in the nation simply because they play in inferior conferences why not allow the SEC championship game decide the national champ then....


bama most likely not gonna win conference, shouldnt have chance for the title...:nono:



and dont give me the packers didnt win their division argument....if there was a playoffs in college football, i would glady say i have no problem with bama winning it as a "wildcard", but when you have the bcs set up to decide the best teams from each confrence, dont think two teams from same confrence should ever be in big game...


just my opinion
 
D

Dragon Fly

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 13, 2008
449
6
0
rematch for what so les miles can out coach saban again hell noooooooooooooooooooo boringgggggggggggggggggggggggg :popcorn2
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Bet on MyBookie
Top