imho, I like Kyle Boller. Indy will focus on stopping the run and force Boller to beat them with the pass. And he has the talent and enough weapons to do so. Heap is finally healthy and this will only help Boller get his numbers. Also, I have noticed that when Indy and Baltimore gets together...they get into a shootout in the 2nd half of the game and the game ends up being a very high scoring one.
Brooks has been erratic at best with an inconsistent receiving core in Horn and Stalworth. Will probably be a lot of short drives (maybe 3 and outs) if the Bucs get off early and the Saints are forced to come from behind. Saints have the talent at the 3 star positions QB, RB, and WR, but have not performed all year. I don't think it starts this week.
Kitna will be my last choice. Buffalo's defense just scares me fantasy wise. Not sure Rudi will be able to take the pressure off Kitna long enough for him to be effective.
McCown would be my 2nd choice. Like him. Arizona has nothing to lose. Just playing their best trying to execute plays. Talented receiving core.
In any case, good luck. I would go with Boller.