Is McCain Too Old?

AR182

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 9, 2000
18,654
87
0
Scottsdale,AZ
i found this an interesting read...but then again i'm voting for mccain...

By RYAN COLE
February 27, 2008; Page A16

John McCain will turn 72 in August. If he goes on to win the presidency in November he will be the oldest American to enter that high office.

Though his opponents have only nibbled around the corners of the issue, Mr. McCain's age will certainly emerge as the presidential sweepstakes unfold. Indeed, it is likely to be a prime target of his would-be Democratic opponent in the general election. This will especially be the case if he is pitted against the 46-year-old Barack Obama.


Mr. McCain's own genetic material appears to be strong -- his 96-year-old mother Roberta has been in tow on the campaign trail. And the rigors of campaigning are surely an indicator of who is or is not physically fit for the job. Still, is Mr. McCain "too old to be president?" A glance at modern history might help answer this question.

Winston Churchill was 65 when he became prime minister of Great Britain in 1940. When the curtain fell on the European theater of World War II in 1945, he was 70. He became prime minister again in 1951 at the age of 76; when he left office in 1955 he was 80. In his tenures, he rallied and inspired Britain to victory in World War II, and set the West's course in another battle against totalitarianism at the dawn of the Cold War.

Konrad Adenauer became the first chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany in 1949 at the age of 73. He remained chancellor until his retirement in 1963 at the age of 87. As the first postwar German head of state, he sired the modern democratic Germany from the ashes of Nazism. He helped resurrect that nation from the devastation and destruction of World War II while presiding over West Germany's reconciliation with and reincorporation into the West.

In 1958, at 68, Charles de Gaulle was elected the first president of the Fifth Republic of France. He held this office until retiring in 1969 at the age of 78. He oversaw the creation of modern France as an independent European power with an important role on the world stage. His economic policies stabilized the postwar French economy. It was de Gaulle who reached a cease fire with the Algerian National Liberation Front, paving the way for Algerian independence and defusing the great obstacle to peace in postwar France.

Golda Meir was 70 when she became the fourth prime minister of Israel. Serving until she was 76, she was in office during the massacre of the Israeli Soccer Team at the 1972 Munich Olympics. It was Meir, frustrated by the lack of international action to address Palestinian terrorism, who marshaled the Mossad to strike back at the operatives who perpetrated the attacks. She also presided over Israel's victory in the Yom Kippur War.

In 1994, Nelson Mandela -- after 27 years in prison -- became the first democratically elected president of South Africa. He was 75 at the time. His was a presidency that witnessed that nation's transition from apartheid to integrated democratic rule. He managed the delicate and difficult task of reconciliation between black and white South Africans. Mr. Mandela served as president until his retirement at the age of 80.

And of course, Ronald Reagan, now commonly ranked among the greatest American presidents, was 69 when he became president of the United States in 1981 and 77 when he left office in 1989. He presided over the end of the Cold War, the fall of the Soviet Union, and the restoration of America's pride and confidence after the traumatic succession of Vietnam, Watergate and Jimmy Carter.


This diverse group of leaders shares a common denominator: They faced trying challenges in office and held the reins of power at momentous times in their country's history. They each had a great impact on their respective countries that continues to this today. They are remembered by their accomplishments -- great and visionary war-time leadership, rapprochement and reconciliation in the shadow of war and racial division, and steadfast commitment to defeating the last century's threats to peace and freedom. They are not remembered for their age at the time they entered office.

True enough, age can bring its share of infirmities. But with age can also come knowledge, understanding and expertise. Prior to becoming heads of state, many great leaders were soldiers, generals, ambassadors, activists, political prisoners, governors and ordinary citizens involved for decades with the political system of their respective countries. Some of that same patina can be seen on John McCain's r?sum?.

Given this precedent, a strong case can be made that age should not be a factor in picking our next president -- unless Mr. McCain, to paraphrase Reagan's famous quip to Walter Mondale, chooses to exploit, for political purposes, his opponent's youth and inexperience.
 

djv

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 4, 2000
13,817
17
0
To OLD? YES. Look at how Clinton and Bush looked like when taking office. And how old after 4 and 8 years. They were both considered young. Im 66 and can tell you the changes I have seen to myself and im very active worked out 5 days a week. Just can't see anyone at 72 taking it on. Unless he's going to sit in corner and do little. And we can't have that. As for Reagan he did good his first 4 years. His last 2 to 3 years he didn't know chit. Nancy was reading the tea leafs and helping him run things. We can't have it again.
 

bryanz

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 8, 2001
9,724
35
48
64
Syracuse ny, usa
There are so many examples of why we cant use a broad brush to assess someones cognitive abilities because of age. Most of us who know people in their 80's can attest to this. Mccain seems as sharp as he's always been. I don't see why age should be an issue with him. Physically or mentally. John is not old in the traditional sense. He is old in his mindset.
 

bryanz

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 8, 2001
9,724
35
48
64
Syracuse ny, usa
I just see the world different than he does. He may be right and I could be wrong but I think he's antiqated. Like an old ball coach, the game has passed him by. I think his strenght is his weakness...
 

Chadman

Realist
Forum Member
Apr 2, 2000
7,501
42
48
SW Missouri
At this point in time, I would not avoid voting for McCain because of his age. I would give a longer look to his VP choice, though, because of his age, and allow that to enter into my thinking. When push comes to shove I will probably vote democratic, but I do like McCain.
 

danmurphy jr

Registered User
Forum Member
Sep 14, 2004
2,966
5
0
Moot point, he doesn't have a prayer. Would Romney or Huckabee as VP candidates alleviate some of the age fears??
 

DOGS THAT BARK

Registered User
Forum Member
Jul 13, 1999
19,514
210
63
Bowling Green Ky
age not relevent if can function mentally--could name several that fuctioned well way past that-greenspan-kissinger to name a few--however in agreement with Chad--VP becomes more important.
 

Chadman

Realist
Forum Member
Apr 2, 2000
7,501
42
48
SW Missouri
Disagree strongly. No way Obama beats him. Hillary possibly, but not Obama. And with Nader in the mix now, McCain would have to screw it up royally to not win.

Not going to argue these points, although I certainly don't agree with them, or the one before it. Just find it interesting in talking and listening to supporters of all three candidates...so many people really feel strongly that either Clinton or Obama specifically have a worse chance against McCain - not really an argumentative or spiteful commentary, just their feeling about it.

It's looking more like the nominee will be Obama, which does surprise me - I gave Clinton more credit than I should have, I think, and have felt all along that the country would be more ready to accept a woman than a black as President when push comes to shove (which it might...:SIB ). But many feel differently - and I'm talking mainly about white, middle to upper "class" white people.

I've said for a while now that I don't see how people can still say that any of these people can't possibly win in November. They have all shared that mantra from time to time. I think any of them could, especially after what we've seen to this point.
 

hedgehog

Registered
Forum Member
Oct 30, 2003
32,883
692
113
50
TX
I think he is too old, but think about the alternative

given that he has my vote, lets just hope he chooses his vice president carefully, maybe Mitt Romney
 

ga_ben

Snarky
Forum Member
Oct 12, 2006
946
6
0
Acworth, GA
I don't think McCain (or any repub) has a snowball's chance against Obamafaintamania. Against Hillary I would like our chances more. It isn't that McCain is too old its just that he isn't likely to get the base revved up and out to the polls. But, hell, I'm sick of all these empty suited (and pantsuited politicians).
 

hedgehog

Registered
Forum Member
Oct 30, 2003
32,883
692
113
50
TX
I don't think McCain (or any repub) has a snowball's chance against Obamafaintamania. Against Hillary I would like our chances more. It isn't that McCain is too old its just that he isn't likely to get the base revved up and out to the polls. But, hell, I'm sick of all these empty suited (and pantsuited politicians).

I think if Obama runs against McCain, McCain will win in a landslide, Obama will be exposed as the phony we all know he is, given time to expose him. He has so many skeletons in the closet it is almost a cemetary, just wait.
 

ga_ben

Snarky
Forum Member
Oct 12, 2006
946
6
0
Acworth, GA
I think if Obama runs against McCain, McCain will win in a landslide, Obama will be exposed as the phony we all know he is, given time to expose him. He has so many skeletons in the closet it is almost a cemetary, just wait.


I really hope you are right. But I would certainly think the Clintons would've flung open the closet door by now if there were any.
 

Chadman

Realist
Forum Member
Apr 2, 2000
7,501
42
48
SW Missouri
Has anyone seen the MSNBC McCain feature? I caught part of it last night, and it showed what he went through as a POW. I guess I never knew how much he endured, and in such a strong way. Made me admire him all the more.
 

Toledo Prophet

Registered User
Forum Member
Oct 5, 2005
2,384
2
0
53
Toledo, Ohio
If it is Obama vs McCain, it would be the greatest age gap between presidential candidates in the general election in our history.

Just a factoid, which I think will be talked about all summer and fall if it gets to that.

Would have loved a chance to vote for McCain in the 2000 General Election......he would have been a much stronger president that Bush has been.....not even close........he might still get my vote this time around, but I am not as enamored with him this time around......I think he, not to mention our country, would be better off had he stayed an adversary of our current president, rather than the cuddle up to routine he's been doing in recent years.

He loses points there in my book, but it would be pretty cool to see Obama and McCain go head to head with the better candidate winning.......i think for Independents, they would have two good candidates to choose from and maybe we get an issue driven campaign for once.

Yeah right, I'll put the pipe down right now! :142smilie
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top