Over-rated! Five college football teams with too much hype

AR182

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 9, 2000
18,654
87
0
Scottsdale,AZ
right now i have no opinion whether i agree with hayes or not.....but from the little that i have read on texas tech, i think they will do pretty well this year...

Matt Hayes/Sporting News

Five overrated teams -- Florida State isn't in anyone's preseason top 25 but makes the list based on reputation -- waiting to be exposed this fall:

Florida State. All you need to know about the 'Noles: They lost badly to Wake Forest the past two seasons. Granted, the Deacs are now among the ACC's elite, but these programs don't recruit in the same hemisphere. Yet if you line up the two teams and we choose for a pickup game, I'm taking Wake players at just about every position.

FSU teams of late play with no heart -- just bravado that's gone by the second quarter. You can have the high school All-Americans who talk big and play small. I'll take the guys no one wanted who have everything to prove. FSU had one player -- one -- last season who played hard every down: wideout Preston Parker. And he went and left a loaded gun under the dashboard of his car.

Hello, mediocrity.

Texas. First, a disclaimer: Considering the depleted numbers on defense last fall, Mack Brown did the best coaching job of his career getting 10 wins out of the Longhorns.

A year later, what do we have? Essentially the same defense and an offense that has no legitimate tailback and no deep threat at wide receiver. And you thought quarterback Colt McCoy regressed last season.

It's a testament to Brown and what he has built that Texas is ranked in the top 10 of nearly every preseason poll. But this team isn't close to top 10-caliber; it'll be lucky to stumble into the Cotton Bowl.

The culprits: Recruits who haven't panned out. Players such as all-world linebacker Sergio Kindle and five-star defensive end Eddie Jones.

Arizona State. Here's an interesting factoid: ASU was Pac-10 co-champion last fall -- and didn't beat a team with a pulse. I'm all for reclamation stories, but ASU's turnaround under coach Dennis Erickson was nothing more than a team playing in a watered-down league and still losing its three toughest games of the season (USC, Oregon, Texas).

Now this ASU team must deal with key losses on both sides of the ball. It does have quarterback Rudy Carpenter -- but it also has his enigmatic ways. Factor the pluses and minuses and it's not a good combination for a team that is in most everyone's top 15 this spring.

The road map to a meltdown: a little nonconference tilt the third weekend of September against SEC heavyweight Georgia, followed by conference road games against California and USC. Everyone on the train to 6-6ville.

Clemson. The Tigers a top 10 team? I've seen this before. Plug and play, everyone: Woody Dantzler, Charlie Whitehurst, Cullen Harper. Start fast, finish slow; stumble at the start, sprint to the finish. What's the difference? It washes out to seven or so wins and coach Tommy Bowden feeling heat.

The only change this time: Bowden's recent contract extension all but guarantees his safety. I'm not buying Clemson until someone on that staff realizes C.J. Spiller actually plays for the Tigers. One of the game's most dynamic running backs somehow touched the ball just 16.5 times a game (that includes punt and kickoff returns) last season -- a monumental increase from the 13.2 in 2006.

Absolutely dumbfounding.

Texas Tech. Kid you not: Heard a television bobblehead the other day say the Red Raiders are his sleeper pick to make it to a BCS game -- and maybe even more. Tech will score on everyone this fall. There's quarterback Graham Harrell and wideout Michael Crabtree, plus a few other guys who will get 60-70 catches, too. To this, I say: So?

It's the other side of the ball that has kept Tech from resembling anything close to a Big 12 contender. The defense played well the second half of last season after Ruffin McNeill took over as coordinator but still gave up 127 points to Missouri, Texas and Oklahoma. Those aren't BCS numbers. Those are the numbers of a team waiting to be exposed.
 

rawli007

lives
Forum Member
Jan 28, 2008
1,986
0
0
Alabama
Let me rant...

Let me rant...

Not to mention all the FSU players that graduated or moved on... they have very few returning starters. I dont know who has "hyped" them to Matt Hayes... none to me.

And i actually think Clemson could surprise some people.. I watched their spring game (i know, its just a spring game), but they ran some new/interesting plays on offense... looks like they may have some tricks up their sleeves.. i thought they looked solid, but yea... just a spring game.

:talk:

I had never read Matt Hayes, but i like these articles/topics.
 

intelsource

Registered User
Forum Member
Sep 22, 2007
51
0
0
Regarding Texas, they had Co-DC's last year after Chizik left and that was a make-shift arrangement that failed miserably. This year they bring in Will Muschamp who was Auburn's DC the past two years and they should be much better on Def. I like their schedule (only 4 road games, all winnable IMO) and think they get at least 10 wins.
 

Sun Tzu

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 10, 2003
6,197
9
0
Houston, Texas
Texas is going to be at least a 3 loss team this year. They have no real weapons on offense and will have secondary troubles. OU is a loss this year, at tech and kansas are serious problems as is the game against Mizzou. Muschamp is a big boost but last I checked we still have Greg Davis as well.
 

Cie

Registered
Forum Member
Apr 30, 2003
22,391
253
0
New Orleans
Texas is going to be at least a 3 loss team this year. They have no real weapons on offense and will have secondary troubles. OU is a loss this year, at tech and kansas are serious problems as is the game against Mizzou. Muschamp is a big boost but last I checked we still have Greg Davis as well.

Sun-

Gotta hand it to you on Perriloux. You were right all along, the guy is a jackass. Word in BR is that multiple incidents were swept under the rug. He was rude to waiters, bartenders, retail clerks and pretty much anyone else he came in contact with. A buddy of mine from BR says he could have been booked with disturbing the peace on a weekly basis.

BTW, what do you know about Russel Shepard? I see he's listed as #1 running QB @ Rivals.
 

Dice34

Off parole
Forum Member
Dec 18, 2004
4,731
27
0
D.O.C.
Sun-

Gotta hand it to you on Perriloux. You were right all along, the guy is a jackass. Word in BR is that multiple incidents were swept under the rug. He was rude to waiters, bartenders, retail clerks and pretty much anyone else he came in contact with. A buddy of mine from BR says he could have been booked with disturbing the peace on a weekly basis.

BTW, what do you know about Russel Shepard? I see he's listed as #1 running QB @ Rivals.

sun would know more than me, since he lives down there.....but Russell is talked about in like vince young fashion........Michigan and RR highly coveted him.....but they ended up getting a verbal from Kevin Newsome.....LSU will be happy with mr. shepard
 

Sun Tzu

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 10, 2003
6,197
9
0
Houston, Texas
Hard to say about RS. Right now he simply cannot throw the football - as far as passing he might not be a top 25 QB in the State of Texas. The kid wanted to go to Texas his whole life and Mack Brown told him he wont be a QB but he would take him as an athlete and RS said no thanks.

There are quite few knowledgable folks that think he is a WR and that Gump sold him a bill of goods to get him. No doubt he is an outstanding runner. But he isnt Vince...not even close.

I still wish Texas had taken him and given him a shot to play QB and then if it doesnt work move him to WR. But Texas also wanted to make sure it keeps Gilbert (nations #2 QB) and offering RS as a QB may have run him off.

IMO RS should have gone to Michigan....from what I have seen of him that is the system he need to succeed at QB.
 

dlvlsu

Registered
Forum Member
Aug 29, 2002
588
2
0
Bet the Gump knows more than you or the other idiots in texas! Bet the Gump wins more games in a stronger conference than any idiot coach in Small 12 also!! I like the way people criticize others when their team or coach sucks worse!!
 

Kramer

Registered User
Forum Member
May 10, 2006
3,631
26
48
Totally agree with Florida State. I remember last
year I felt BB bringing in what I thought were a
great new coaching changes and I thought they
would make a statement. They made a statement
all right. That program is stale as three year old
....well whatever the f$ck gets stale. :mj07:
 

ET4646

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 31, 2003
1,568
20
38
Bet the Gump knows more than you or the other idiots in texas! Bet the Gump wins more games in a stronger conference than any idiot coach in Small 12 also!! I like the way people criticize others when their team or coach sucks worse!!

Oh No:eek:
 

Destructor D

Destructor
Forum Member
Dec 6, 2005
8,632
133
63
Kansas City, MO
Big 12 is going to be top heavy with some solid teams. Oklahoma, Missouri, Texas Tech, Kansas, and Texas could all be top 15 teams. Kansas and Texas play the other 4 teams so they'll probably take their lumps.

Watch out for Missouri! They have a decent shot at going undefeated IMO. They avoid OU and their toughest game is @ Texas.
 

dlvlsu

Registered
Forum Member
Aug 29, 2002
588
2
0
How about the SEC Kicking ass and taking names even after beating each other up all year! Toughest conference in the country will win another National championship this year! Mark it down.
 

thebsmanofkent

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 28, 2006
314
0
0
Kent, WA
Hey AR182, I was in your neck of the woods a couple weeks ago, doin' the Grand Canyon thing,
coming in from Phoenix...

Florida State is in a meltdown. Until they get rid of Bobby, that program will continue to work it's way down. It's pathetic. They've been in this dilemma now for at least 5+ yrs.
I know, I am a Noles fan, but it's been hard
to see this team with talent go nowhere.

Bring on the season.
 

sdf

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 22, 2002
1,336
88
48
Texas is going to be at least a 3 loss team this year. They have no real weapons on offense and will have secondary troubles. OU is a loss this year, at tech and kansas are serious problems as is the game against Mizzou. Muschamp is a big boost but last I checked we still have Greg Davis as well.

did Mack learn anything from the bowl game vs ASU? He prepped that team well, kept them loose, worked them hard but had fun. He worked in some trick plays on offense and also has some versatility at QB this year with Chiles.

Texas lost Charles on offense and have no real big threat in the backfield this year, but their OL should be much better than last year and that should mean more protection for Colt and bigger holes for the running game.

The defense loses a LOT, but frankly they werent all that good last year and should improve with a good DC.

losing to OU? check
losing at TT? maybe, but we havent lost in Lubbock many times...thanks Chris Simms!
losing at KU? possible. they will still be VG even though they lost some key players. again, Texas hasnt lost to KU often

Texas' schedule for the TT/KU games also shapes up a little better than their opponent.

TT has at TAMU and at KU before facing Texas.
Texas hosts OSU just before the game at TT
--
Texas hosts Baylor just before KU
KU has at OU, TT, KSU and at NU before facing Texas.

definitely some ?s for Texas but with a stronger OL, a much better DC, and lowered expectations, I think they might actually do pretty well. that is, if, Mack learned from last year's bowl game. If he goes back to playing tight, close to the vest football, then he and Davis could give them a mediocre year.

should be fun
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top