ISSUE: Without Michael Strahan and Osi Umenyiora, the season is over before it starts.
DISCUSSION: No, but it does mean that the Giants have lost one of the strengths of their defense, which is depth. They are able to overcome the Umenyiora loss by moving Mathias Kiwanuka back to his natural position at defensive end, but they will not be able to withstand another key injury to their front seven. They're starting the season with Plan B, which is dangerous, because like hurricane names, plans have a tendency to run through the alphabet during a football season.
ISSUE: The Giants are a better team without Jeremy Shockey.
DISCUSSION: If by team you mean a group of individuals who come together to achieve a common goal, then yes, the Giants are much better off. But if by better you mean they'll be able to score more points, rush and pass for more yardage, then no. There are ways to sidestep Shockey's absence on the field with different formations and responsibilities, but ultimately Shockey was a more productive tight end than anyone the Giants have there now.
ISSUE: The Giants will suffer through an inevitable Super Bowl hangover.
DISCUSSION: Every team coming off a Super Bowl victory stands up in the summer and says they won't. And then they do. So what makes the Giants think they can avoid the letdown? Probably the fact that despite the rings and the trophies they are still perceived as a fluke champion, an undeserving winner. Teams rarely emerge from the Super Bowl with the chip on their shoulder still intact. The Giants have theirs, and it's a 10-table chip to match their rings.
ISSUE: Eli Manning can't possibly continue playing at the level he set during the playoffs.
DISCUSSION: Hate to point this out, but there will be times during the next 16 games in which Manning looks uncomfortable, makes poor decisions and throws interceptions. Brace yourself. He will not be perfect. But Manning will be much better and more consistent than he was during the 2007 regular season. The confidence capital he accrued in January will help him come out of any swoons faster than he would have a year ago. He's already done the Super Bowl thing; maybe this season he tries the Pro Bowl.
DISCUSSION: No, but it does mean that the Giants have lost one of the strengths of their defense, which is depth. They are able to overcome the Umenyiora loss by moving Mathias Kiwanuka back to his natural position at defensive end, but they will not be able to withstand another key injury to their front seven. They're starting the season with Plan B, which is dangerous, because like hurricane names, plans have a tendency to run through the alphabet during a football season.
ISSUE: The Giants are a better team without Jeremy Shockey.
DISCUSSION: If by team you mean a group of individuals who come together to achieve a common goal, then yes, the Giants are much better off. But if by better you mean they'll be able to score more points, rush and pass for more yardage, then no. There are ways to sidestep Shockey's absence on the field with different formations and responsibilities, but ultimately Shockey was a more productive tight end than anyone the Giants have there now.
ISSUE: The Giants will suffer through an inevitable Super Bowl hangover.
DISCUSSION: Every team coming off a Super Bowl victory stands up in the summer and says they won't. And then they do. So what makes the Giants think they can avoid the letdown? Probably the fact that despite the rings and the trophies they are still perceived as a fluke champion, an undeserving winner. Teams rarely emerge from the Super Bowl with the chip on their shoulder still intact. The Giants have theirs, and it's a 10-table chip to match their rings.
ISSUE: Eli Manning can't possibly continue playing at the level he set during the playoffs.
DISCUSSION: Hate to point this out, but there will be times during the next 16 games in which Manning looks uncomfortable, makes poor decisions and throws interceptions. Brace yourself. He will not be perfect. But Manning will be much better and more consistent than he was during the 2007 regular season. The confidence capital he accrued in January will help him come out of any swoons faster than he would have a year ago. He's already done the Super Bowl thing; maybe this season he tries the Pro Bowl.