Would you sit Tebow this week?

Lumi

LOKI
Forum Member
Aug 30, 2002
21,104
58
0
58
In the shadows
For the health and well being of the kid, I would keep him on the bench, in street clothes, no where near any football gear. One more week to clear his head. Severe head trauma is nothing to mess with, especially concussions. I have had 5 and a fractured skull. That explains allot huh? :mj07:
 

THE KOD

Registered
Forum Member
Nov 16, 2001
42,499
263
83
Victory Lane
Normally a doctor would not clear him to play this soon after a concussion.

Maybe he will sit.

No way to tell right now.

Or he may get whacked early and have to go out again.

Right now I am off this game.

I dont care much for ifs and buts
 

layinwood

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 29, 2001
4,771
40
0
Dallas, TX
I don't think there's anyway he plays in this game. He's done as much for this program as any kid has ever done for any. I think his future is too important to mess with and yes I think he has a future in the NFL. I also don't think they need him to play. I think the game will be close with or without him and even if they lose they just have to win out to be in the NC game so why risk it.
 

CWood97

Registered User
Forum Member
Jan 6, 2003
2,041
4
38
Michigan
Urban would be an idiot not to sit him. If he doesn't play and you lose, then the media/pollsters will excuse the loss. As long as they don't lose again they go to the BCS champ game. USC already has a loss. All the contenders in in the B10 have a loss. If FL wins out they can give Bama or LSU a loss in the SEC champ game. Texas is undefeated, so that's your likely opposition. There's simply no way an undefeated Boise/Cinci gets in over a one loss FLA.

Basically, you lose this game without Tebow, and it doesn't matter. Now, you lose this game WITH Tebow and you're in the same boat with all the other one loss teams.
 

Cie

Registered
Forum Member
Apr 30, 2003
22,391
253
0
New Orleans
Urban would be an idiot not to sit him. If he doesn't play and you lose, then the media/pollsters will excuse the loss. As long as they don't lose again they go to the BCS champ game. USC already has a loss. All the contenders in in the B10 have a loss. If FL wins out they can give Bama or LSU a loss in the SEC champ game. Texas is undefeated, so that's your likely opposition. There's simply no way an undefeated Boise/Cinci gets in over a one loss FLA.

Basically, you lose this game without Tebow, and it doesn't matter. Now, you lose this game WITH Tebow and you're in the same boat with all the other one loss teams.

IMO, Tebow will not play in this game.
 

sdf

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 22, 2002
1,329
85
48
USC already has a loss. All the contenders in in the B10 have a loss.


Iowa is undefeated and already beat another contender on the road

USC could make the same claim as UF...they lost the game with their backup.


i think if TT is cleared to play, he will play. It will all come down to the doc's decision
 

RollTide72

June 8, 2013
Forum Member
Apr 4, 2002
5,401
39
0
53
Greenfield, IN
www.facebook.com
I definitely believe that you sit him for this game. Did I read somewhere that said if Tebow was in the MMA he wouldn't be allowed to fight for a month? Two weeks after taking a vicious blow against an aggressive defense is just rolling the dice in my opinion.

From College Football News...

All of a sudden, everyone has become a neurologist and knows what?s wrong with Tim Tebow?s bruised brain and what needs to be done to make sure it?s fine and able to withstand the punishment of playing football again. What no one seems to be talking about are the non-football ramifications. Because Florida plays a monster game at LSU on Saturday night, that CBS is giving the primetime spot for in place of whatever dopey CSI Whispering Mentalist thing it normally would?ve showed, Tebow?s injury is being analyzed and scrutinized like he was a pro. Forget about playing football; how about trying to concentrate in the classroom (and I mean this for all players who suffer a concussion and now necessarily Tebow, who's only taking one class)?

Lost in the world of college football is that injured players still have to study, walk to class, sit in class, try to learn, and try to lead a normal student life. Try doing any of those things after suffering a major concussion. Try sitting through an extended lecture for over an hour with a throbbing shoulder with pain that isn?t going away even after taking ten Advil. Try writing notes or typing on a computer with sore fingers that have been jammed and banged on over and over again. Try focusing on absorbing the material when you have a bruised rib that you feel every time you breathe.

We?ve all had injuries, aches, and pains of some sort that make life hard, but concussions are at another level. This is all about the doctors when it comes to Tebow, and it?s all about making sure the next 60 years of his life are spent with a clear mind and without the horrors of being sensitive to light, headaches, mood swings, memory loss, and all the other problems that are certain to follow. But Tebow is at the University of Florida to play football, and football players live with concussions and injuries. Just remember that the next time you question whether or not they?re supposed to be treated just like regular students.
 

hedgehog

Registered
Forum Member
Oct 30, 2003
32,866
670
113
50
TX
Meyer is paid to win games, if doctors clear him of course he plays

If Tebow is smart he will sit the game out and completely recover before he comes back, he has a career in the NFL to think about.

I wonder if Tebows dad has any say, isn't he a doctor?
 

Rebel21

Registered User
Forum Member
Sep 4, 2002
840
3
0
44
there is alot more stuff out now about "2nd hit syndrome" which is basically the increased risk you have after your first major concussion...that is if you get hit while your brain is still reeling from the previous injury.

the doctors taking care of him, and yes actually i am an md, i'm sure will not make a brash decision just because of the levity of the game. they will have his best interest in mind and Meyer willl likely follow suit with whatever conclusion they come to.

my prediction: there is no way he plays.
 

Lumi

LOKI
Forum Member
Aug 30, 2002
21,104
58
0
58
In the shadows
When I got my first concussion and skull fracture, I was 9, I was held out of sports for 18 months. Including running, jumping, skipping :142smilie bike riding, skate boarding, I could only sit in a pool and calmly drift around. At the beach I had to sit in the water ankle deep.

It really sucked, have you ever tried to keep a 9 year old still?

Granted, Timmy isn't 9, but he is a well tuned machine that want's to go 150 mph all the time. I know and understand the glazed look, the rubber legs and everything else that comes with a severe head shot. If he plays and there is a play called where he has to hit a LB, the concussion isn't going to cross his mind at that moment, getting the 1st down or TD is all that matters, because that's the way Tim is, balls to the wall, 150 MPH. I hope he doesn't play, I don't want to see another kid have his future damaged because he returned too early from an injury.
 

THE KOD

Registered
Forum Member
Nov 16, 2001
42,499
263
83
Victory Lane
KOD,

Would you as the head coach sit him
..............................................................


Honestly if I were the head coach I would sit him and play Brantley.

Wins are important but Tebow will stick his head in again , and could really get hurt bad. Like career ending.

I think he will be a fantastic NFL QB.

A really good person to.
 

Betone

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 24, 2004
16,268
294
83
66
Monument, CO
I say NO, he will not play as that would be ridiculous. Lose a game vs a career and possible championship would end Urban Meyers career as well.
 

THE KOD

Registered
Forum Member
Nov 16, 2001
42,499
263
83
Victory Lane
Florida is not stupid.

They know that by keeping Tebow playing up in the air, it makes it more difficult to prepare a game plan for Brantly at QB

if LSU is smart they will prepare like Tebow aint playing , because I doubt seriously that he is.
 

hedgehog

Registered
Forum Member
Oct 30, 2003
32,866
670
113
50
TX
he will play, I don't think he should either, I just think he will, I wonder what the line will be at gametime? I would play the up in the air game, like Scotty said Florida is not stupid. LSU wins either way
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top