BCS's new poll won't start until after season begins

IE

Administrator
Forum Admin
Forum Member
Mar 15, 1999
95,440
223
63
(AP) -- The Bowl Championship Series has created a new college football poll with a unique twist -- games will be played before ballots are cast.

Called the Harris Interactive College Football Poll, it will rank the top 25 teams on a weekly basis, starting Sept. 25 -- four weeks into the season. Plans call for 114 voters. The panel will be comprised of former coaches, players and administrators, plus media members.

The BCS has said it would like to see the elimination of preseason polls, which some believe give highly touted teams an unfair headstart in the rankings. ``This allows for some games to be played in the current season rather than allow teams to be ranked purely on preseason expectations,'' BCS coordinator and Big 12 commissioner Kevin Weiberg said Monday during a conference call.

The season's first BCS standings will be released Oct. 17.

The new poll replaces The Associated Press poll, which the BCS had used in its formula for ranking teams since 1998. Last season, however, the AP told the BCS it could no longer use its media poll.

In addition to the new poll, the BCS will continue to use the USA Today coaches' poll and a compilation of six computer rankings -- each counting for one-third of a team's grade. The coaches will continue with a preseason ballot.

Recently, ESPN pulled out of participating in the coaches poll.

The coaches agreed to have their final ballots made public for the first time this season. The new Harris poll will take the same approach, releasing only the final ballots.

When Texas made up late ground on California in the BCS standings last season and grabbed a spot in the Rose Bowl, Cal and Pac-10 officials called for the coaches' votes to be made public.

The AP poll never provided a secret ballot for its voters.

``We thought it was important for there to be consistency with the two human polls,'' Weiberg said. ``To make the ballots public on a weekly basis during the season, we feel the focus would be on who voted for whom and detract from the games being playing.''

Last season, the BCS standings emphasized the polls more than ever and AP voters' ballots were scrutinized as three unbeaten teams competed for the top two spots.

Weiberg said voters in the new poll will be allowed to make their votes public at any point in the season if they choose.

``We've made very good progress in terms of people responding affirmatively to wanting to be part of the poll,'' he said.

The AP preseason poll will be released Aug. 20, with the first regular-season poll Sept. 6. The AP national champion will be crowned after the Rose Bowl on Jan. 4.

Last season, Southern California and Oklahoma held the top two spots in both the AP and coaches' polls in the preseason and kept those positions throughout undefeated regular seasons.

Auburn, which began the season ranked in the teens in the polls, went unbeaten but never could pass the Trojans or Sooners in the polls. USC finished No. 1 in the final BCS standings and Oklahoma was No. 2, mostly on the strength of their top-ranked computer score.

All three teams finished the regular season unbeaten and USC and Oklahoma played for the national title in the Orange Bowl. Auburn went to the Sugar Bowl, finished the season 13-0 and had to settle for a final ranking of No. 2 in the polls behind national champion USC.

Auburn coach Tommy Tuberville said the preseason rankings put his team at a disadvantage because they had too much ground to make up in the BCS standings before games were even played.

Harris Interactive Inc., a marketing company hired by the BCS last month to coordinate the new poll, is in the process of compiling a panel from 300 possible participants. Voters' names will be made public and all 11 Division I-A conferences and independent teams will be represented in the panel.

Each conference nominated 27 people to be placed into a pool of possible poll voters, and each conference will have 10 of its nominees in the panel.
 

THE KOD

Registered
Forum Member
Nov 16, 2001
42,561
314
83
Victory Lane
another article on this


By TONY BARNHART
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Published on: 07/11/05
The newest player in the Bowl Championship Series formula will be bigger, slower and, college football fans hope, smarter.

BCS officials confirmed Monday that the Harris Interactive College Football Poll will be the third component in the equation that determines the sport's national champion, replacing The Associated Press Top 25.


HOW IT WORKS

The Bowl Championship Series revealed its formula for deciding college football's championship standings Monday. Each component counts for one-third:
? USA Today coaches poll. Sixty-one coaches will vote, with the final regular-season ballots being made public. ESPN is no longer a sponsor.
? Harris Interactive poll. Takes the place of the AP poll; panel will include 114 voters, whose names will be made public. Poll starts Sept. 25.
? Six computer rankings. The six rankings used last season will be back in 2005: Anderson & Hester, Richard Billingsley, Colley Matrix, Kenneth Massey, Jeff Sagarin and Peter Wolfe.


The poll will have 114 voters whose identities will be revealed closer to the season and will launch on Sept. 25, three weeks before the first BCS standings are announced. That means most teams will have played three or four games before the first vote takes place.

"This allows for some games to be played in the current season rather than allow teams to be ranked purely on preseason expectations," BCS coordinator Kevin Weiberg said.

The USA Today coaches poll will continue to publish its first poll in the preseason despite a pitch by Auburn coach Tommy Tuberville that it not begin until October.

The polls came under scrutiny last season when Tuberville's 12-0 Tigers were shut out of the championship game in favor of Southern Cal and Oklahoma. Those two teams held the top two spots in the preseason polls and never fell ? on the field or in the minds of voters.

"The preseason poll helps set the stage for fans," said Monte Lorell, USA Today's managing editor for sports. "It gives an early look at who's considered strong heading into the season, who to watch. And from a competitive standpoint, we want our readers to get a sense of what the coaches are thinking.

"Without that early look, fans won't have a guidepost until five or six weeks into the season when the BCS poll is released."

The two polls and the average of six computer rankings will each count for one-third of the BCS poll, the same breakdown as last season.

The Harris poll panel will be made up of former coaches, athletics administrators and media. About 20 percent of the 114 voters will come from the media. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution will not have a participant because company policy prohibits its writers from voting on such polls.

Former Georgia athletics director Vince Dooley said Monday night he has been contacted by the Harris group about voting, but hasn't determined if he'll be able to participate.

Harris officials said Monday they've filled more than 80 of the 114 voting spots. They anticipate lining up the rest in the coming weeks and will announce the names of the voters prior to the first games.

Weiberg said the BCS commissioners discussed the possibility of simply forming a selection committee to pick the teams in the four BCS games (Fiesta, Sugar, Orange, Rose), but a consensus couldn't be reached on who would make up the committee and how it would operate.

"So we decided that the practical thing to do was to have as little change as possible from the old system," Weiberg said.

There is one significant change.

Both the Harris and coaches polls will make public their final regular-season ballots on Dec. 4. This season will mark the first time the coaches have agreed to release their ballots to the public. The ballots in the AP poll have always been available on a weekly basis.

Weiberg said any voter in the Harris poll who wanted to make his ballot public will be free to do so.
 

Stuman

Banned
Forum Member
Nov 5, 2002
800
0
0
Memphrica, Tennessee
I think this is a good move but....

The fact that the BCS system gets tweaked every year tells us one thing - IT'S NOT WORKING!!

Give us what we all want...a playoff.

:scared What a concept! :scared
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top