I'm glad to see some others on Cleveland, as that is in fact the way I was going to play it unless something big came up that made me switch to a no play.
The Indians have one of the best lineups in all of baseball against left handed pitchers whereas the Yankees have one of the worst against lefties. Finley has been dominant against NYY in the past, posting a 16-9 mark with a 3.31 ERA in 34 games. The addition of Rocker also should help against the Yankees, considering he is a lefty and he has had success against Yanks this season, converting 2 out of 2 save opportunities.
Keisler has struggled so far this year. In his only appearance against the Indians last year, he went 2/3 of an inning while getting blasted for 6 runs.
I'm looking for the Indians to jump on Keisler early and Rocker to close it out late.
Cleveland -110 Best bet
GL to all tonight