College Football voting - found this interesting

KotysDad

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 6, 2001
1,206
7
38
Read this in my local newspaper this morning. Found it interesting. Some fact mixed with some opinion.........As if there needs to be another reason to wish for a playoff structure in college football.

--------------------------------------------


A bit of deception in coaches' slant pattern

This week, the individual votes by the coaches who make up the ESPN/USA Today college football poll were revealed. And the lesson should be that bias - so often said to be rampant in the media - is alive and well in the coaching ranks.

At SI.com, Stewart Mandel picked out some examples of coaches, like most of us, operate out of self-interest - or some odd logic.

Oregon coach Mike Bellotti, hoping his team would get a Bowl Championship Series bowl spot, voted his own team fourth while placing the Ducks' rival for a BCS spot, Notre Dame, at No. 9.

In the same vein, Ohio State's Jim Tressel, up against Oregon for one of those BCS berths, voted his Buckeyes fourth and Oregon ninth.

It may be almost heaven, but Arkansas' Houston Nutt completely forgot about West Virginia, leaving the Big East champion out of his Top 25. :nutkick

According to an analysis by the Notre Dame blog "Blue-Gray Sky," "Eight of the 13 coaches who voted Oregon seventh or lower came from the two conferences that had teams vying with the Ducks for a BCS at-large spot, SEC [Auburn] and Big Ten [Ohio State]."

Then again, maybe all of those votes were just honest opinions. As in, those coaches honestly want to help themselves and their conferences.
 

Blazer

ontherocks
Forum Member
Jan 4, 2003
3,201
3
0
48
Nashville
www.madjacksports.com
Just so you know.....

Just so you know.....

Texas coach Mack Brown has been calling Southern California the No. 1 team all season and it wasn?t just talk.
Brown voted USC first in the final USA Today coaches? poll ? and so did his brother.
The ballots were made public Monday, a first for the coaches? poll, which is used by the Bowl Championship Series in its standings formula.

The BCS had urged the coaches to remove the secrecy in their poll after the 2004 season, when Texas made a late surge in the polls to earn a Rose Bowl bid over California.
The coaches decided to release only their final ballots, which were printed in Monday?s editions of USA Today.
?I think it proves what we thought it would all along, which is that the coaches who vote in the USA Today coaches? poll are thoughtful and committed to the balloting process,? Grant Teaff, executive director of the American Football Coaches Association, said Monday through spokesman Todd Bell.
The Harris Interactive poll, which was introduced this season to replace The Associated Press Top 25 in the BCS formula, also released its final ballots. The Harris panel is comprised of former college football players, coaches and administrators, plus some media members.
The AP media poll has always had transparency in its voting.
Brown had his Texas team No. 2, behind USC. The Trojans and Longhorns will play for the national title in the Rose Bowl on Jan. 4.
UAB coach Watson Brown also had the Trojans first and his younger brother?s team second.
USC coach Pete Carroll is not on the 62-member voting panel. Twenty coaches voted for their own teams, with none straying too far from the consensus.
Among the notables, Rutgers coach Greg Schiano gave the Scarlet Knights (7-4) their only vote, putting them 25th on his ballot.
Notre Dame coach Charlie Weis had his team fourth, two spots ahead of Oregon (10-1). The Fighting Irish (9-2) were ranked No. 6.
Oregon coach Mike Bellotti put the Ducks fourth and Notre Dame ninth. Oregon finished No. 5 in the final regular season poll, but Notre Dame earned a bid to the BCS and Oregon did not.
Texas received seven first-place votes to USC?s 55.
 

Dice34

Off parole
Forum Member
Dec 18, 2004
4,731
27
0
D.O.C.
you think Jim tressel is bias? He only put 7 Big 10 teams in the top 25.......thanks for the link bjfinste...........after looking at more coaches hes not the only one.....that is a joke, of course their is going to be bias from the coaches and their conferences....we need a playoff.....I guess Bill Doba is not a fan of the ACC, leaving off Boston College, Florida State and Georgia Tech and finding room for Oklahoma and California and putting UCLA ahead of Notre Dame..... :wtf:

Great I'm supposed to be selling Nascar toys today and instead I'll be looking at this for hours
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top