Congratulations to all Buckeye fans

The Judge

Pura Vida!
Forum Member
Aug 5, 2004
4,909
29
0
SJO
It is not an easy task to come into Darrell Royal Memorial Stadium and dominate the Texas Longhorns the way that the Ohio State Buckeyes did tonight . My hat is off to Coach Tressell and his fine football team.

CTownguy and Kosar, please post a link in this thread to the cap that you would like for me to aquire for you and send me your mailing addresses.

It is now time for me to be drunk.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scotter

Sun Tzu

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 10, 2003
6,197
9
0
Houston, Texas
I think we learned tonight that without Vince Young Mack and Greg Davis are what they always were. Nothing liike 4 yard passes on 3rd and 8 and 12 yard cushions for wide receivers.
 

The Judge

Pura Vida!
Forum Member
Aug 5, 2004
4,909
29
0
SJO
I think we learned tonight that without Vince Young Mack and Greg Davis are what they always were. Nothing liike 4 yard passes on 3rd and 8 and 12 yard cushions for wide receivers.
This loss is squarely on Davis' shoulders. The play calling was horrific.
 

Texas-Hookem

Registered User
Forum Member
Aug 18, 2006
17
0
1
This loss is squarely on Davis' shoulders. The play calling was horrific.
Absolutely agree Judge. Back to the play calling pre-Vince. We are successful with the running game so what does he do, he has 5 straight pass plays (including the Pittman fumble).

Congrats Buckeye's, a very good win and a great team. Good luck the rest of the season. I really don't see us losing another game this year with our schedule so maybe there's an outside chance we'll meet up again in Arizona.
 

ctownguy

Life is Good
Forum Member
Jul 27, 2000
3,065
16
0
SoCal
Thanks Judge.

I know it was a very tough loss, I had that feeling last year. We'll get drunk together next time in Vegas on you of course:mj07:

I'll be in touch my friend.
 

thom24ad

UDFlyers
Forum Member
Sep 29, 2005
2,124
0
0
45
Columbus, OH
sorry Judge but it looks like I should have taken your -10 bet during the summer...Overall I don't see Texas losing another game this season and I agree some of the play calling was very questionable...Its too bad the two programs can't meet more often...what an atmosphere last night...Texas has some of the classiest fans that I have ever came across...What was it like there in Austin?...would you say OSU fans travel or what?
 

Deezeldogg

O-H-I-O
Forum Member
Jul 15, 2006
306
1
0
Cambridge, Ohio
This was about what I had expected, but I didn't want to shoot my mouth off. I felt OSU was pretty conservative on defense against Northern Illinois. And tho they still didn't seem to blitz a whole lot, they did enough to keep McCoy under control. He's going to be a great player. I just hope OSU can run the ball better. If they stay balanced on O, they should racck up some points. I was also impressed that Troy Smith didn't have to rely on his feet much.
 

BobbyBlueChip

Trustee
Forum Member
Dec 27, 2000
20,712
289
83
53
Belly of the Beast
I was also impressed that Troy Smith didn't have to rely on his feet much.

I actually think that Smith's distaste for the running aspect of the game is the most likely thing to cost them a game this year.

Nice showing for the Buckeyes and this season may not be over for the Lonhorns - it all depends on how far they drop. I hope it's not much so teams are encouraged to schedule these types of games, but they should have never moved up last week.
 

kosar

Centrist
Forum Member
Nov 27, 1999
11,112
55
0
ft myers, fl
I actually think that Smith's distaste for the running aspect of the game is the most likely thing to cost them a game this year.

Nice showing for the Buckeyes and this season may not be over for the Lonhorns - it all depends on how far they drop. I hope it's not much so teams are encouraged to schedule these types of games, but they should have never moved up last week.

They dropped to 8th in the coaches poll, probably a couple spots lower than I would have thought. USC#2 and ND#3. Your fighting Irish looked awfully impressive, Bobby.

Not sure who said what, but definitely agree that Texas HAD to pound the runs and/or the slip screens to win this game. They had all SORTS of room between the tackles between OSU's d-line and linebackers almost every time they ran plays like that.

Ripping off 5 to 10 yards almost every time. McCoy is extremely inexperienced and I figured that would, or very likely could be the difference compared to Smith. They had room to move against the front 7, and were never really being blown out, and I believed they passed too much at certain times.

Even the 2 or so intermediate passes that McCoy completed were pretty shaky. Just kind of flung/floated out there and if a defender had just turned around, it would have been batted down, at least.

Very few of Smiths completions were in doubt, even with defenders in the area because he fires missiles in there. There was not one pass of his that whole game that even had a chance of being intercepted.

Not worried at all about OSU's running game. They will be good enough to supplement what will surely be a passy-happy offense.

I don't agree with Bobby that Smith's focus on the pass, rather than the run, will cost them a game. He makes 10x the amount of plays/completions after he *could* have run than it would have happened that it would have been better for him to run. If that makes any sense.

OSU's tackling was atrocious and if anything, this kicker will make things interesting in a game or two or even cost them a game. After 5 years of Nugent and Houston, we have become spoiled.

A couple other notes. Smith is a better passer than Young, period. Young is huge and a force, but as a pure passer? No way.

When Mack Brown was interviewed about using his challenge in about the first 2 seconds of the game instead of late in the game as he had said he would, he said, 'one of my kids said it was a bad call. It was a mistake.'

ONE OF HIS KIDS SAID IT WAS A BAD CALL? Yeah, probably the guy who fumbled it. Does he not have communication with his booth upstairs? WTF is wrong with him? I know you Texas guys always get on him and with things like that I can see why.


Whatever the case, as mentioned above by fellow Buckeye fans, we felt this same agony around this time last year. We can relate.

And also as mentioned above, after your win last year and your loss last year, you all have been nothing but classy.

There was no bigger Texas fan against USC last year and they came through brilliantly.

Unusual high-profile home and home match-ups like this are always great, no matter the teams.

Judge,

I'll find a hat link and post it here. Thanks, man.
 

3 Seconds

Fcuk Frist
Forum Member
Jan 14, 2004
6,706
16
0
Marlton, NJ
I agree that Smith is a much better passer than young.

Also agree that our tackling and placekicking stinks!!


No one said pure passer, the statement was VY is a MUCH better college QB.

To say the Smith is close to VY is just silly.

VY is one of the greatest college QBs ever to play. Are you saying that is what Smith is as well?
 

Deezeldogg

O-H-I-O
Forum Member
Jul 15, 2006
306
1
0
Cambridge, Ohio
No one said pure passer, the statement was VY is a MUCH better college QB.

To say the Smith is close to VY is just silly.

VY is one of the greatest college QBs ever to play. Are you saying that is what Smith is as well?

I believe he will be by the end of the year. If Bucks run the table, he will be the Heisman winner. But I don't think Smith or Young will do anything great in the NFL.
 

kosar

Centrist
Forum Member
Nov 27, 1999
11,112
55
0
ft myers, fl
No one said pure passer, the statement was VY is a MUCH better college QB.

To say the Smith is close to VY is just silly.

VY is one of the greatest college QBs ever to play. Are you saying that is what Smith is as well?


As best as I can tell, deezeldog has only said that Smith is a better passer.

For various reasons, including some idiotic decisions by Smith off the field, Vince will have had a much longer college career on the field.

Time will tell about the pros, as Vince has 2 inches on Smith and about, what, 30 pounds? But the development of Smith since he was named the sole QB has been unbeliveable. I love Tressel, but his game plan agains Penn State last year was ignorant.

He didn't know what he had and played it conservative as hell, resulting in another loss.

Actually, that's on Smith as well, because if he hadn't been such a jackoff off the field, Tressel would already know his abilities because he would have actually been on the field.

Smith's bs/suspension/etc cost them those games.

That said, he has been amazing in big games(see Michigan, Notre Dame, Texas), small games and everything in between since then and there is no question that he is a much more accurate passer than Young. Not even close.

But no, of course, VY will go down as the better college QB. I totally agree.
 

3 Seconds

Fcuk Frist
Forum Member
Jan 14, 2004
6,706
16
0
Marlton, NJ
As best as I can tell, deezeldog has only said that Smith is a better passer.

For various reasons, including some idiotic decisions by Smith off the field, Vince will have had a much longer college career on the field.

But no, of course, VY will go down as the better college QB. I totally agree.

Thank you.

Vince has about 4 inches on Troy as VY is 6'5.
 

3 Seconds

Fcuk Frist
Forum Member
Jan 14, 2004
6,706
16
0
Marlton, NJ
I believe he will be by the end of the year. If Bucks run the table, he will be the Heisman winner. But I don't think Smith or Young will do anything great in the NFL.

Please take off the homer glasses.

No one is talking about the NFL, although I can guarantee you Troy Smith has a 0% of being a top 3 pick like VY.

Just so I have this straight....you think Troy Smith is going to go down as one of the best QBs to ever play college football????

:nono:
 

thom24ad

UDFlyers
Forum Member
Sep 29, 2005
2,124
0
0
45
Columbus, OH
Please take off the homer glasses.

No one is talking about the NFL, although I can guarantee you Troy Smith has a 0% of being a top 3 pick like VY.

Just so I have this straight....you think Troy Smith is going to go down as one of the best QBs to ever play college football????

:nono:

I'm Buckeye fan...personally I think he could win an Heisman if the Bucks go undefeated only due to the amount of big games he has won but I still think Quinn is the best QB in the NCAA...Smith should be a 3rd round pick at the highest...
 
Last edited:

kosar

Centrist
Forum Member
Nov 27, 1999
11,112
55
0
ft myers, fl
Please take off the homer glasses.

No one is talking about the NFL, although I can guarantee you Troy Smith has a 0% of being a top 3 pick like VY.

Just so I have this straight....you think Troy Smith is going to go down as one of the best QBs to ever play college football????

:nono:

3 seconds, are we reading the same thread? I don't know this deezeldog guy, but I don't see where he said that Smith was going down as one of the best QB's in history.

As far as the Heisman, of course he will be the front-runner as long as he keeps playing like this and they stay undefeated or one loss.

If everything goes to form, it will take Quinn having a huge game with a win at USC for him to win it. Or at the very least, it will be very close.

Who cares about that anyways?

As far as the pros go? As always, time will tell. And no, lol, Troy Smith will not be picked 3rd overall. Not sure that's really the benchmark as far as NFL 'success' goes, though. Tim Couch, Akili Smith, Alex Smith...etc..etc. Could go on forever.

You know what I mean?

Success in the NFL means success in the NFL. Period. It doesn't mean how fooled scouts were with regard to their college careers and the wasted high draft picks.

Not saying Vince falls into that category, but just sayin' that draft placement is no indication of anything.

We'll see. :)
 

3 Seconds

Fcuk Frist
Forum Member
Jan 14, 2004
6,706
16
0
Marlton, NJ
3 seconds, are we reading the same thread? I don't know this deezeldog guy, but I don't see where he said that Smith was going down as one of the best QB's in history.

As far as the Heisman, of course he will be the front-runner as long as he keeps playing like this and they stay undefeated or one loss.

If everything goes to form, it will take Quinn having a huge game with a win at USC for him to win it. Or at the very least, it will be very close.

Who cares about that anyways?

As far as the pros go? As always, time will tell. And no, lol, Troy Smith will not be picked 3rd overall. Not sure that's really the benchmark as far as NFL 'success' goes, though. Tim Couch, Akili Smith, Alex Smith...etc..etc. Could go on forever.

You know what I mean?

Success in the NFL means success in the NFL. Period. It doesn't mean how fooled scouts were with regard to their college careers and the wasted high draft picks.

Not saying Vince falls into that category, but just sayin' that draft placement is no indication of anything.

We'll see. :)

Completely agree about Heisman for Smith.

I agree that draft spot is not indicitive of pro success, but that is a indicator of both your college performance & pro potential. That is all I was saying.
 
Last edited:
Bet on MyBookie
Top