Free Press sports writer Helene St. James breaks down the matchups between the Red Wings and the Penguins:
Forwards
Both teams have fearsome top lines, headlined by the Wings' Pavel Datsyuk and Henrik Zetterberg and the Penguins' Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin. The Penguins paid big for Marian Hossa at the trade deadline, but he has been worth it. Wingers Ryan Malone and Pascal Dupuis are threats, too, and third-line center Jordan Staal can be counted on for big goals. Tomas Holmstrom is key for the Wings because of his net-front style, as is Johan Franzen's return from concussion-like symptoms. All in all, these are two staggeringly talented offenses.
Edge: Even
Defense
Sergei Gonchar should have been a finalist for the Norris Trophy; he's great on the point and anchors the first pairing opposite Brooks Orpik. Kris Letang is underrated considering his ability to mesh with partner Ryan Whitney. Hal Gill towers on the third pairing with Rob Scuderi. No pairing is more puck-adept, though, than Nicklas Lidstrom and Brian Rafalski, and Brad Stuart and Niklas Kronwall provide offense and big hits on the second pairing. Brett Lebda is a good puck mover on the third pairing, opposite either Chris Chelios or Andreas Lilja.
Edge: Wings
Goaltending
Chris Osgood has an NHL-best 1.60 goals-against average, and Pittsburgh's Marc-Andre Fleury is right behind at 1.70. Fleury's league-high .938 save percentage is slightly above Osgood's .931. Fleury has faced 388 shots, 100 more than Osgood, who plays behind a better overall team defense. Osgood backstopped the 1998 Wings to the Cup; Fleury, a former No. 1 pick, is experiencing the playoffs for only the second time.
Edge: Even
Special teams
Discipline can't be overstated for either team because both are lethal with the man advantage. The Wings are very aggressive penalty killers -- with five shorthanded goals in the playoffs to the Penguins' one -- but have the same success rate as Pittsburgh at 87.3%, third-best in the playoffs this season.
Edge: Even
Coach
Mike Babcock has turned the Wings into a hard-driving, adaptable team, and is willing to make changes on the fly. Michel Therrien used Sidney Crosby's midseason ankle injury to hone the Penguins' defensive play, a major weakness for the young team last year.
Edge: Even
Intangibles
The Penguins burst with youthful exuberance. The Wings are a playoff-experienced team, including a run all the way to the conference finals last year. That, ultimately, should make the difference in returning the Stanley Cup to Hockeytown.
Edge: Wings
Prediction: Wings in six.
Forwards
Both teams have fearsome top lines, headlined by the Wings' Pavel Datsyuk and Henrik Zetterberg and the Penguins' Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin. The Penguins paid big for Marian Hossa at the trade deadline, but he has been worth it. Wingers Ryan Malone and Pascal Dupuis are threats, too, and third-line center Jordan Staal can be counted on for big goals. Tomas Holmstrom is key for the Wings because of his net-front style, as is Johan Franzen's return from concussion-like symptoms. All in all, these are two staggeringly talented offenses.
Edge: Even
Defense
Sergei Gonchar should have been a finalist for the Norris Trophy; he's great on the point and anchors the first pairing opposite Brooks Orpik. Kris Letang is underrated considering his ability to mesh with partner Ryan Whitney. Hal Gill towers on the third pairing with Rob Scuderi. No pairing is more puck-adept, though, than Nicklas Lidstrom and Brian Rafalski, and Brad Stuart and Niklas Kronwall provide offense and big hits on the second pairing. Brett Lebda is a good puck mover on the third pairing, opposite either Chris Chelios or Andreas Lilja.
Edge: Wings
Goaltending
Chris Osgood has an NHL-best 1.60 goals-against average, and Pittsburgh's Marc-Andre Fleury is right behind at 1.70. Fleury's league-high .938 save percentage is slightly above Osgood's .931. Fleury has faced 388 shots, 100 more than Osgood, who plays behind a better overall team defense. Osgood backstopped the 1998 Wings to the Cup; Fleury, a former No. 1 pick, is experiencing the playoffs for only the second time.
Edge: Even
Special teams
Discipline can't be overstated for either team because both are lethal with the man advantage. The Wings are very aggressive penalty killers -- with five shorthanded goals in the playoffs to the Penguins' one -- but have the same success rate as Pittsburgh at 87.3%, third-best in the playoffs this season.
Edge: Even
Coach
Mike Babcock has turned the Wings into a hard-driving, adaptable team, and is willing to make changes on the fly. Michel Therrien used Sidney Crosby's midseason ankle injury to hone the Penguins' defensive play, a major weakness for the young team last year.
Edge: Even
Intangibles
The Penguins burst with youthful exuberance. The Wings are a playoff-experienced team, including a run all the way to the conference finals last year. That, ultimately, should make the difference in returning the Stanley Cup to Hockeytown.
Edge: Wings
Prediction: Wings in six.
