There cannot be any debate anymore right?
As a fan who always preferred peyton to Tom, and even now prefers Brees, it's hard to admit but hes the goat....dude has been in 9 sbs and is 6-3 in them
He did it in early 2000s with no protecting players and different rules
He did it 6-7 years ago and beat the vaunted Seattle defense
He did it vs Atlanta with the biggest comeback in SB history
And he did it this year at age 41 with clutch passing and really only 1 WR....I mean did Hogan and Dorsett even dress?
The guy has had more clutch game sealing drives in the post season then most qbs have in entire careers (like tonite 2X)
I love manning and as a younger fan I was a little kid when Montana was doing his thing, but I have watched all of playoff games since then to see his greatness, but even his resume cannot match up any longer.
The only arguments are few.....
1. Hes a product of belichek
Having the best coach helps but he still had to execute....
and
2. hes been a verified cheater.....but deflated footballs werent why they won it that year...
The dudes the best ever
Hes beat some really good teams
Rams and greatest show on turf
Carolina with the defense
Philly with mcmabb and T.O
Seattle and legion of boom
ATL with a 28-3 deficit
And now the rams with the best player in Donald in the league and the hottest upcoming coach in the league
I am glad I got to witness it
Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk
As a fan who always preferred peyton to Tom, and even now prefers Brees, it's hard to admit but hes the goat....dude has been in 9 sbs and is 6-3 in them
He did it in early 2000s with no protecting players and different rules
He did it 6-7 years ago and beat the vaunted Seattle defense
He did it vs Atlanta with the biggest comeback in SB history
And he did it this year at age 41 with clutch passing and really only 1 WR....I mean did Hogan and Dorsett even dress?
The guy has had more clutch game sealing drives in the post season then most qbs have in entire careers (like tonite 2X)
I love manning and as a younger fan I was a little kid when Montana was doing his thing, but I have watched all of playoff games since then to see his greatness, but even his resume cannot match up any longer.
The only arguments are few.....
1. Hes a product of belichek
Having the best coach helps but he still had to execute....
and
2. hes been a verified cheater.....but deflated footballs werent why they won it that year...
The dudes the best ever
Hes beat some really good teams
Rams and greatest show on turf
Carolina with the defense
Philly with mcmabb and T.O
Seattle and legion of boom
ATL with a 28-3 deficit
And now the rams with the best player in Donald in the league and the hottest upcoming coach in the league
I am glad I got to witness it
Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk
Last edited:
