Ted Ginn vs Dwayne Jarrett.....who will be the better pro??

maverick2112

Registered User
Forum Member
Jan 16, 2001
2,967
5
38
Wyoming
Who would you draft between these 2 if you needed a WR....?????

I like Ginn's speed be Jarrett sure is a load........I think I would take Jarrett.........
 

Scott4USC

Fight On!
Forum Member
Sep 11, 2002
5,410
18
38
44
Who would you draft between these 2 if you needed a WR....?????

I like Ginn's speed be Jarrett sure is a load........I think I would take Jarrett.........

Tough choice. I might take Ginn.

Jarret isn't physical. Only thing I do not like about him and his game. Jarret needs another year of college IMO.
 

gjn23

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 20, 2002
9,319
45
48
54
So. Cal
ginn

jarrett has little speed and will be a mike williams clone in the nfl
 

Scott4USC

Fight On!
Forum Member
Sep 11, 2002
5,410
18
38
44
ginn

jarrett has little speed and will be a mike williams clone in the nfl

I agree. Funny thing is, Mike Williams dominated college football like no recent WR i have seen. And he was only a freshman and sophomore. AMAZING COLLEGE WR. Guess he should try and become a TE or change teams in NFL.
 

maverick2112

Registered User
Forum Member
Jan 16, 2001
2,967
5
38
Wyoming
I agree. Funny thing is, Mike Williams dominated college football like no recent WR i have seen. And he was only a freshman and sophomore. AMAZING COLLEGE WR. Guess he should try and become a TE or change teams in NFL.


Playing in Detroit cant help much.........
 

gman2

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 12, 2002
9,827
16
0
interesting. the west coast people say ginn.
im a midwest ohio guy and say jarrett. ginn drops way WAY too many passes. he is an amazing deep threat and dynamic kick returner. but he's not a good route runner and doesnt always make the routine plays. ive always contended (as scott knows) that jarrett is the best usc receiver since keyshawn.
 

Dr. Fade

Colllector
Forum Member
Sep 29, 2005
1,476
17
0
Kansas City
Calvin Johnson will definitely be drafted higher than both and will be better. Ginn is a better college player, similar to Peter Warick but better. I think Jarrett will be a solid pro (better than Ginn), but Calvin Johnson has game changing skillz
 

blgstocks

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 4, 2005
3,181
12
0
So. Cal
Calvin Johnson will definitely be drafted higher than both and will be better. Ginn is a better college player, similar to Peter Warick but better. I think Jarrett will be a solid pro (better than Ginn), but Calvin Johnson has game changing skillz

I agree, if we are taking CJ into acct its not even close imo. But between Ginn and Jarret I will take Jarret. Catches better, runs cleaner routes, has better size. As many have found out, you need more than speed to compete at the next level.
 

The Big Tease

DUKE SUCKS
Forum Member
Mar 9, 2000
2,788
1
0
46
Columbus,OH USA
interesting. the west coast people say ginn.
im a midwest ohio guy and say jarrett. ginn drops way WAY too many passes. he is an amazing deep threat and dynamic kick returner. but he's not a good route runner and doesnt always make the routine plays. ive always contended (as scott knows) that jarrett is the best usc receiver since keyshawn.

As usual, I agree with gman2....word for word
 

The Big Tease

DUKE SUCKS
Forum Member
Mar 9, 2000
2,788
1
0
46
Columbus,OH USA
interesting. the west coast people say ginn.
im a midwest ohio guy and say jarrett. ginn drops way WAY too many passes. he is an amazing deep threat and dynamic kick returner. but he's not a good route runner and doesnt always make the routine plays. ive always contended (as scott knows) that jarrett is the best usc receiver since keyshawn.

I am telling you right now......Ginn will be the third most talented receiver the Buckeyes have on their roster in the NFL.

1.) Robieski
2.) Gonzalez
3.) Ginn
 

Chill

Registered User
Forum Member
Sep 12, 2005
668
4
0
agree robiske will be better than the other two.


I'd take jarret over ginn.

jarret could be a threat in red zone, Ginn looks like a punt returner to me, not polished enough.
 

Scott4USC

Fight On!
Forum Member
Sep 11, 2002
5,410
18
38
44
Jarret sleep walks during games, lazy on routes etc. He also isn't physical and can be pushed around. You don't think NFL DB's will be physical with him? I have not been impressed with him this sesaon. I expected much better. He still is top 5 CFB WR but he can be a lot better. Although his catch last night in endzone was thing of beauty.

You can't teach speed and GINN can be taught to catch ball better and run better routes. Both prob. should stay another year in college.
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top