Top 40 Players for 2004

Master Capper

Emperior
Forum Member
Jan 12, 2002
9,104
11
0
Dunedin, Florida
1. WR Mike Williams, Jr. USC 6-5 220
Williams would?ve been a top 20 pick after his freshman year and should be a top five selection when he jumps to the NFL. He?s not a blazer, but he has everything else with great quickness for a player of his size, peerless hands, and the size to outmuscle any defensive back.

2. CB Antrel Rolle, Sr. Miami 6-1 205
The Miami corner should?ve turned pro early following his fantastic performance against Pittsburgh?s Larry Fitzgerald. He?s the total package with great speed to go along with his size.

3. RB Carnell Williams, Sr. Auburn 5-10 205
It?s not inconceivable that Williams could be the number one pick in the 2005 draft. He proved that the broken leg suffered in 2002 wasn?t an issue running as well as ever despite the issues the rest of the Tigers had. He?s a workhorse with unparalleled quickness and moves when sizing up a defender one-on-one.

4. DE Marcus Spears, Sr. LSU 6-4 295
Spears is a scary blend of size and athleticism. Originally a tight end, Spears moved over to the defensive side early in his career and became a terror. He became more and more consistent as last season went on as one of the SEC?s premier pass rushers.

5. TE Heath Miller, Jr. Virginia 6-5 255
A big blocker with tremendous hands, he should be college football?s best tight end this year and will rise higher on the charts if he continues to shine around the goal line.

6. QB Dan Orlovsky, Sr. Connecticut 6-5 230
Orlovsky might quickly grow into a top-ten caliber pick if he can cut down a bit on his interceptions. He?s a big passer with a big, and normally accurate arm.

7. DE David Pollack, Sr. Georgia 6-3 275
Pollack didn?t live up to his sophomore season, but he was still ultra-productive and proved he could still dominate even though he was a bit dinged up. No prospect has the work ethic and motor that Pollack has.

8. OT Jammal Brown. Sr. Oklahoma 6-6 305
With all due respect to Tommie Harris, Brown might have been the most sure pro prospect on the 2003 team. He still needs a little bit of overall work, but he?s emerging as one of the top pass protectors.

9. WR Braylon Edwards, Sr. Michigan 6-2 205
Edwards turned into an elite receiver last season making more big deep plays and turning into a terror around the goal line. He needs to improve his concentration and consistency, but his athleticism is undeniable.

10. DT Shaun Cody, Sr. USC 6-4 280
The most versatile of the Wild Bunch II, the former end has gotten over his knee injury to become a tremendous tackle. He has a fantastic work ethic and has a motor that always runs.


11. CB Carlos Rogers, Sr. Auburn 6-1 195
Rogers should be in the NFL. He?s big, quick and athletic able to lock down on the best of receivers and can hit as well as any safety.

12. WR Mark Clayton, Sr. Oklahoma 5-11 180
Clayton lived up to his star promise with an All-America 2003 season. He?s not huge, but his leaping ability and breakaway speed more than make up for his size.

13. CB Corey Webster, Sr. LSU 6-2 200
Webster must really love Baton Rouge to postpone his million dollar payday for a year. Few corners in college football have been as good with the ball in the air and can also hit.

14. LB Derrick Johnson, Sr. Texas 6-4 230
Johnson might not be the fastest linebacker in college football, but he certainly plays like it. He could?ve been a high draft pick this year and comes back to be the preseason favorite for the Butkus Award. Texas isn?t known for being a team that plays with a ton of heart, but that doesn?t apply to Johnson.

15. RB Cedric Benson, Sr. Texas 5-11 215
The light bulb went on last year for Benson as he might have been the best running back in college football over the second half of the season. He showed the power, speed and workhorse ability Longhorn fans have been waiting for.

16. DE Marquise Hill, Sr. LSU 6-7 295
A tackle sized player with the quickness of an end, Hill should be in the NFL already. Instead, he returns for his senior season needing to become a little more consistent and could use the time to get even bigger.

17. QB Andrew Walter, Sr. Arizona State 6-5 220
Many have dismissed Walter after the Sun Devils had a disappointing season, but if anything, his stock should rise because of 2003. He was a warrior playing hurt week after week and still putting up decent numbers. He?s not fast, but he?s a good athlete with a tremendous arm and great accuracy both in the pocket and on the move.

18. OT Rob Petitti, Sr. Pittsburgh 6-6 330
A sure-fire top early pick because of his size, Petitti is a punishing run blocker and a killer once he?s able to lock up on a lineman. His overall technique and footwork could use a bit of fine-tuning, so he could make big strides in his senior year.

19. WR Geoff McArthur, Sr. California 6-1 200 Sr.
McArthur exploded with a huge 2003 making 85 catches for 1,504 yards and ten touchdowns. The only down size is his health having hamstring problems early in his career and a broken arm late last year.

20. RB Ronnie Brown, Sr. Auburn 6-1 225
As good as Carnell Williams is, Brown might be an even better pro prospect. He?s a big back with a tremendous burst of speed able to hit the home-run once past the line. The other positive? Brown is an elite back without a lot of wear and tear only carrying the ball 354 times so far. By comparison, Williams ran the ball 241 times last year.

21. OT Alex Barron Sr. Florida State 6-6 320
A big body with quick feet, he could progress into one of the top tackle prospects as the best player on what will be a great Seminole offensive line.

22. OG C.J. Brooks, Sr. Maryland 6-6 325
A mauling run blocker, Brooks would?ve been a solid NFL prospect if he left early. He?ll be the anchor of the line this year.

23. S Jamaal Brimmer, Sr. UNLV 6-1 205
Brimmer isn?t the fastest defensive back around, but he?s not slow by any means and there are few able to make the plays he does. Whatever you need, Brimmer can do it from rushing the passer to coming up with the big hit to helping out on any deep ball.

24. DT Anttaj Hawthorne, Sr. Wisconsin 6-3 300
Hawthorne stood out in the great win over Ohio State as a premier run clogger. He?s also outstanding at busting through the line to make plays in the backfield.

25. OG David Baas, Sr. Michigan 6-4 300
Baas is as athletic and quick as a 300-pound guard can be. He was one of the main reasons Chris Perry had so much success running up the middle. He should?ve been off to the NFL after his 2003 season.

26. LB Kirk Morrison, Sr. San Diego State 6-2 240
Morrison should be in the NFL right now. There might not be another linebacker in college football with his size and speed to get to the ball. His stock should quickly rise as the season goes on.

27. RB Wali Lundy, Jr. Virginia 6-1, 215
A versatile big back with a good nose for the goal line, great receiving skills and speed, Lundy needs to get more carries to get more of a pro buzz. He could be the best all-around pro prospect package of running back skills.

28. WR Martin Nance, Jr. Miami University 6-4 215
Miami wasn?t all Big Ben last year. Nance became the team?s most dangerous deep threat quickly earning Roethlisberger?s trust in the clutch.

29. CB Justin Miller, Jr. Clemson 5-11 180
He might be a little too cocky for his own good, but that?s not a bad quality in a corner. He?ll be one of the best athletes in the draft whenever he comes out.

30. RB Marion Barber III, Jr. Minnesota 5-11 210
Barber got in better shape and went on a tear in 2003 as one of the best backs in the nation. He has sensation feet to get out of jams and is one of the best red zone runners in the game.

31. QB Matt Leinart, Jr. USC 6-5 215
Leiinart was beyond brilliant in his first season as the Trojan quarterback proving to be every bit as good and as accurate as Heisman Trophy winner Carson Palmer was. He proved he could make every throw and showed the poise of a veteran. The only question is whether or not he can consistently handle pressure since he rarely if ever had anyone in his face.

32. TE Matt Herian, Jr. Nebraska 6-5 240
For what it?s worth, Herian was Nebraska?s top deep receiving threat over the last two years. He?s not a dominating blocker, but he?s not bad. His hands and receiving skills more than make up for any problems.

33. OT Wesley Britt, Sr. Alabama 6-8 320
Britt should?ve been as good as gone to the NFL as one of the top tackle prospects before a broken leg set things back. He won?t be able to play this spring, but he?s expected to return at full strength. He?s one of the most experienced linemen in college football.

34. RB Maurice Clarett, Jr. Ohio State(?) 6-0 230
There?s still the question about whether or not he?ll actually be a Buckeye, but he?ll still be a big-name player with tremendous upside and a freakish ability around the goal line whenever he finally gets his wish to be a pro. There are still major concerns about his durability and character.

35. WR Craphonso Thorpe, Sr. Florida State 6-2 175
An unfortunate leg injury late in the NC State game kept Thorpe from jumping to the NFL this year. He was the team?s most dangerous weapon and should be one of the top receivers if he can regain his pre-injury form. Even though he?s lightning fast, he could use some bulk to handle the NFL pounding.
 

Master Capper

Emperior
Forum Member
Jan 12, 2002
9,104
11
0
Dunedin, Florida
36. DE Chris Canty, Sr. Virginia 6-7 280
Canty started to live up to his promise last year with 104 tackles with the size and athleticism to become something even more special. He?s good at getting into the backfield, but he could be a more consistent pass rusher.

37. DE Loren Howard, Jr. Northwestern 6-4 275
Howard has had to deal with being the focus of the average Wildcat line. He?s able to dominate when one-on-one and is tremendous against the run.

38. RB Walter Reyes, Sr. Syracuse 5-10 205
Reyes has great speed and excellent goal line skills. To borrow a basketball term, there might not be a better pure scorer in college football. He has to prove he can put up big numbers against the elite teams.

39. QB Charlie Frye, Sr. Akron 6-4 215
Frye thought about coming out after his junior year but made a good decision to come back. He might be the best all-around NFL quarterback prospect in college football with an accurate arm to go along with great feet rushing for 17 career scores.

40. CB Marlin Jackson, Sr. Michigan 6-1 190
Jackson had some off-the-field issues and never lived up to the preseason hype. His statistics weren?t there asked to do different things than he did as a sophomore, but he still projects to be a top corner with excellent size and tremendous speed.
 

Scott4USC

Fight On!
Forum Member
Sep 11, 2002
5,410
18
38
45
Thanks for posting this, very interesting. I have to say, Lienart in no way should be ranked #31 and the #3 QB with the numbers he put up last year. Last year was Lienarts first year at QB (yes 1st year with zero experience) and he put up heisman numbers. Now i be first to say he doesn't hve the strongest arm and speed'/agility, but the guy gets the job done. He is very football smart and efficient. You gotta think he will improve from last year, especially since most of the players on offense are returning. :eek: I would put Lienart #1 QB in the nation next year, although he does have the best offensive talent surrounding him. What you think?

Andrew Walter should not be the #2 QB in the country. He has cannon arm but he just does not deserve to be #2.

I agree Carnell Williams is the best "pre-season" RB in the country. That guy is scary good.

It be very cool to bring up this thread at the end of next year and compare the players. I guarantee you that RB Reggie Bush will be on the list.
 

Master Capper

Emperior
Forum Member
Jan 12, 2002
9,104
11
0
Dunedin, Florida
JpBlack: Yes Jason White is coming back these ratings are based on the athletes ability to move onto the next level and Jason White IMO will not be a servicable NFL QB.

Scott:

I would take your man over Walter's but as stated above this is a ranking of the players according to their ability to transcend to the NFL. I think his arm strength is ? to go onto the next level, but he has at least two years to improve on the strength. Frye is a QB that has the skills really to shine in the NFL espically in a West Coast style offense, too bad he is on a average team that has not had a defense in 10 years.
 

Master Capper

Emperior
Forum Member
Jan 12, 2002
9,104
11
0
Dunedin, Florida
41. WR Fred Gibson, Sr. Georgia 6-4 200
Gibson has all the talent in the world with a size, speed and a basketball player?s athletic ability. He has problems with consistency and health dinged up all of last season and occasionally disappearing when needed most.

42. LB Abdul Hodge, Jr. Iowa 6-2 235
A tackling machine, Hodge became one of the rocks of the Hawkeye run defense. His sideline-to-sideline range makes him a hot prospect at any linebacker spot.

43. WR J.R. Russell, Sr. Louisville 6-3 195
Russell won?t get too much national exposure, but he?ll be the featured receiver on what should be a high-octane Cardinal attack. The scouts are going to fall in love with his size and elite deep speed.

44. OG Claude Terrell, Sr. New Mexico 6-3 330
There?s a reason RB DonTrell Moore had so much success running up the middle. Terrell has quickly emerged as one of the nation?s best run blockers.


45. QB Charlie Whitehurst, Jr. Clemson 6-4, 210
Whitehurst has a good arm, nice touch and solid decision making ability. He can go from being a solid prospect to a great one with a big season.

46. DB Atari Bigby, Sr. UCF 5-11 215
His draft stock won?t be all that high because of his size, but Bigby is one of the best all-around defensive backs in America. He might be better suited to corner, his former position, even though he hits like a linebacker.

47. RB Anthony Davis, Sr. Wisconsin 5-8 190
Durability is the only question for the Badger star after failing to get healthy last year after various injuries. He was a workhorse over his first two years and finally broke down. When 100%, there are few backs with the speed burst and quickness Davis has. He has more power than his size would make it seem.

48. DE Bill Swancutt, Sr. Oregon State 6-4 260
The only question is whether or not Swancutt can continue to shine without Dwon Edwards and other good Beaver defensive players to take the heat off. He?s a great all-around lineman great against the run to go along with his tremendous pass rushing abilities.

49. DE Eric Moore, Sr. Florida State 6-4 250
Did Moore turn into a tremendous pass rusher because Darnell Dockett and the rest of the FSU line was so strong, or is Moore that good? Moore needs to add at least ten more pounds, but he?s tremendous as is at getting into the backfield. He could be one of the high-risers as the season goes on.

50. DE Mathias Kiwanuka, Jr. Boston College 6-6 250
A little thin and lanky for an NFL defensive lineman, Kiwanuka needs to add at least 15 pounds of muscle. If he can do that without losing his quick first step, he could literally grow into a first round pick.

51. LB Michael Boley, Sr. Southern Miss 6-3 225
Boley has great speed and can make plays all over the field. He?s a bit lanky and isn?t quite the physical player Rod Davis was, but he might grow into the better overall pro prospect.

52. WR Craig Bragg, Sr. UCLA 6-2, 190

It?s amazing that Bragg was able to have the season he had in 2003 (73 catches for 1,065 yards and five scores) considering how bad the quarterback situation was and how there was no one else on the Bruin attack to help him out. He?s one of college football?s premier home-run hitters when there?s a quarterback to properly get him the ball.

53. C Vince Carter, Jr. Oklahoma 6-3 285
He?s not quite as big as the NFL would like, but there are few centers with Carter?s quickness. If he hits the weights harder and ups his overall strength, he?ll be the best center prospect in the 2005 draft.

54. LB Odell Thurman, Jr. Georgia 6-1 230
The key for Thurman will be to get bigger. He has tremendous range able to get in the backfield without a problem and good enough to seamlessly drop into pass coverage. He proved last year that he can handle the responsibility of directing the Dawg defense from the middle.

55. QB Aaron Rodgers, Jr. California 6-2 195
Rodgers came on at the end of last year to become one of the top prospects worth watching in 2004. He has a huge arm and is getting fantastic coaching under Jeff Tedford.

56. SS James Sanders, Jr. Fresno State 5-11 200
If Sanders could just grow to 6-1, many would think of him as a sure-thing early-round pick. That?s no big deal; he?s great at his size. He?s a great ball-hawk and can hit like a ton of bricks.

57. DE Vinny Burns, Sr. Kentucky 6-2 260
It?ll be asking too much for Sweet Pea to make the meteoric rise up the draft charts that Dewayne Robertson did a few years ago, but he could quickly become a top prospect if he?s able to get to the quarterback like he did last year.

58. WR/KR Charles Frederick, Sr. Washington 6-0 180
With some off-the-field issues behind him, Frederick should shine as the main star in the Husky offense. Few players in college football have his speed and open field moves as Frederick also shines as a kick returner.

59. C Ben Wilkerson, Sr. LSU 6-4 300
Wilkerson could?ve been off to the NFL but he came back for his senior year to be the anchor of the Tiger line. He?s had a few injury issues over the course of his career, but is a big player who doesn?t need a whole bunch of work on any one part of his game.

60. RB Darren Sproles, Sr. Kansas State 5-7 170
Sproles might be puny, but the guy can flat out play. He?s a workhorse with unbelievable quickness and speed. If he gets in the open field, it?s over. No NFL team will think about making him a feature back, but he can certainly be a difference maker.

61. WR Dante Ridgeway, Jr. Ball State 6-0 195
Ridgeway grew into an almost unstoppable receiving force in 2003 even though he never had anything more than an average quarterback throwing to him. He was always able to get open.

62. DE Jovan Haye, Jr. Vanderbilt 6-4 255
Haye exploded last year as a great pass rusher and one of the SEC?s most active tacklers with 73 tackles and nine sacks. He?ll be more of a marked man this season, but he size, strength and quick first step to become a top prospect.

63. DE Justin Tuck, Sr. Notre Dame 6-5 250
Tuck grew from being a pass rushing specialist into a good all-around lineman. He?ll have to prove he can be as productive this year as a marked man and could stand to get a bit bigger.

64. OT Nick Kaczur, Sr. Toledo 6-5 320
Few MAC linemen have progressed as well as Kaczur has. Already an All-MAC caliber player, Kaczur got even better as one of the key cogs in the Rocket attack. He has room to get even stronger and more dominant as a premier quarterback protector.

65. WR Roydell Williams, Sr. Tulane 6-2 185
Williams rebounded from a broken ankle to have a strong junior year. He won?t have a Patrick Ramsey or a J.P. Losman to get him the ball, but he should still shine as one of Conference USA?s most dangerous deep threats.

66. S Andre Maddox, Sr. NC State 6-2 195
Good size and excellent range. He?s better in run coverage than against the pass, but he?s not terrible when the ball is in the air.

67. DE Demarcus Ware, Sr. Troy State 6-5 225
Ware is a premier pass rusher with 32 quarterback hurries last year, but he?s too lanky and could stand to get stronger. Even so, his athleticism is good enough to get him a spot on some NFL squad.

68. RB Lynell Hamilton, Soph. San Diego State 6-1 220
Hamilton is still a year away from being eligible and should shine over the next two years as one of the best running back prospects in college football. He?s big with tremendous speed rushing for 1,087 yards as a true freshman even though there was no one else on the Aztec attack to take the heat off.

69. DE Matt Roth, Sr. Iowa 6-4 260
Roth isn?t a flashy player, but he?s big and quick off the line. A good pass rusher and great against the run, he could turn into an early round pick with another big year.

70. WR Jason Anderson, Sr. Wake Forest 6-3 185
Overlooked because of the offense he plays in, Anderson is a big, fast, fluid receiver who?ll get drafted way too late and will end up being a ten-year pro.
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top