best ever

[Blitz]

i agree .. he make recievers ... the other had good ones

He is a great QB, but he has had some good receivers.

Not saying Brady is the greatest, don't want to look like a homer, but he did win 3 Super Bowls with receivers that were not exactly household names... :shrug:

 

[michaeljbird]

I agree 100%

 

[gardenweasel]

who would you want on that last drive with the game on the line?.....

i say sputnik-head....

 

[MadJack]

elway had the least of anybody....ever....until terrell davis showed up and he won 2 in a row

but to get that crap team he has for 10 years prior to 3 super bowls was amazing

i dont think he had 1 hof player on the roster with him the entire time.....and his wr were average and the rb's were worse

you're right


/thread

 

[serialkiller]

peyton is the best i have ever seen..period..

 

[michaeljbird]

Elway.....run and pass abiilty....hands down

 

[MadJack]

peyton is the best i have ever seen..period..

exactly. period. end of thread. no doubt about it.

:toast:

 

[michaeljbird]

By looking at pictures of Favre's cock.......Id say he has gotten the most out of nothing ???:kiss:

 

[Blitz]

exactly. period. end of thread. no doubt about it.

:toast:

What about Flacco? :shrug: :0074

 

[BasketballNut]

nope he chokes in the playoffs

 

[MadJack]

What about Flacco? :shrug: :0074

now you crossed the line :nono:

 

[the addict]

By looking at pictures of Favre's cock.......Id say he has gotten the most out of nothing ???:kiss:

haha now thats funny....he surely is fishing with a small pole!

 

[the addict]

What about Flacco? :shrug: :0074

if not flacco then henne for sure:mj07:

 

[Blitz]

now you crossed the line :nono:

lol ... he had a good game today...

 

[SoCalYo]

now you crossed the line :nono:

he is second to none in Maryland:toast:

 

[BuckwheatJWN]

Can't believe with all the arguments over "BEST" QB's that people don't talk about the rule changes to protect them. Granted athletes are larger and better today, and one would be a fool to think otherwise. But how great would have Unitas been with being permitted to spike the ball, throw out of bounds when out of the pocket, receivers being more protected, etc. Same with Starr, Tark, Layne, Stabler, and some others. I'm just throwing that in. I'm not necessarily an "old" school guy.

 

[proguy747]

Who played with manning that is going to the hall of fame?

 

[gardenweasel]

Can't believe with all the arguments over "BEST" QB's that people don't talk about the rule changes to protect them. Granted athletes are larger and better today, and one would be a fool to think otherwise. But how great would have Unitas been with being permitted to spike the ball, throw out of bounds when out of the pocket, receivers being more protected, etc. Same with Starr, Tark, Layne, Stabler, and some others. I'm just throwing that in. I'm not necessarily an "old" school guy.

no..but you`re a very wise fellow(with a great moniker)...

excellent points...

 

[Roger Baltrey]

Can't believe with all the arguments over "BEST" QB's that people don't talk about the rule changes to protect them. Granted athletes are larger and better today, and one would be a fool to think otherwise. But how great would have Unitas been with being permitted to spike the ball, throw out of bounds when out of the pocket, receivers being more protected, etc. Same with Starr, Tark, Layne, Stabler, and some others. I'm just throwing that in. I'm not necessarily an "old" school guy.

Pretty sure spiking was around in Unitas's day.

 

[BuckwheatJWN]

About 75% sure spiking wasn't. I think I remember QB's firing the ball out of play to stop the clock, but I'll leave it to someone else to look it up. Hard to buy into greatest ever for Manning for me, anyways. He lost too many big games as a favorite for me to give him the title. I know he was the reason for Colt's being a favorite most the time, but he still has to WIN those games to satisfy me. Like comparing Carlton to Koufax or Spahn in baseball. Besides he's cost me a lot of money in games. FROM the shutout he put up in a playoff game years ago ( I had over) to last years Super Bowl when his interception cost me a "squares" board