I originally did this up to give me some added help in the early going; however, after seeing Senor Capper's post (which I liked very much) I decided to go ahead and post it in case it might possibly help someone else or stir up some thinking on the board.
Legend: Team, RSO-returning starters offense, QB (Y/N), RSD-returning starters defense, SAG - jeff sagarin's opening power rating (USA Today), SUR - straight up record from last year, ATS - spread record from last year, NETATS - ranking by spread record (net ATS wins).
TEAM...............RSO..QB..RSD..SAG...SUR...ATS...NETATS
01...W Virginia........05..Yes..04..77..09-03..09-02..07
02...UConn..............08..Yes..08..58..06-06..09-02..07
03...N Illinois...........07..Yes..06..70..08-04..09-02..07
04...Iowa.................04..No...07..81..11-01..09-03..06
05...Georgia............03..Yes..07..87..12-01..09-03..06
06...Kansas St.........07..Yes..05..90..10-02..08-02..06
07...Bosie St............03..Yes..07..78..11-01..09-03..06
08...Notre Dame......05..Yes..08..83..10-02..09-03..06
09...Auburn.............08..Yes..08..82..08-04..08-03..05
10...N C State..........07..Yes..05..81..10-03..08-03..05
11...Tulane..............09..Yes..03..66..07-05..08-03..05
12...Cincinnati.........05..Yes..04..71..07-06..09-04..05
13...S Florida...........08..No...06..70..09-02..07-02..05
14...San Jose St.......08..Yes..08..64..06-07..09-04..05
15...Toledo...............04..No...08..75..09-04..08-03..05
16...Penn St..............05..Yes..06..83..09-03..08-04..04
17...Kentucky............07..Yes..04..73..07-05..08-04..04
18...So Cal................06..No...06..86..10-02..08-04..04
19...California...........06..No...02..73..07-05..08-04..04
20...Maryland............06..Yes..09..82..10-03..08-04..04
21...Duke...................11..Yes..09..59..02-10..08-04..04
22...Air Force.............07..Yes..06..73..08-04..08-04..04
23...Oklahoma St.......08..Yes..06..74..07-05..07-04..03
24...Colorado.............03..No...06..83..09-04..08-05..03
25...Washington St.....06..No...07..82..10-02..07-04..03
26...Neveda................07..No...10..62..05-07..07-04..03
27...Ohio U.................04..Yes..08..62..04-08..07-04..03
28...Ball St.................05..Yes..07..62..06-06..07-04..03
29...N Texas...............04..Yes..08..65..07-05..07-04..03
30...Arkansas St.........05..Yes..09..53..06-07..07-04..03
31...Purdue................08..Yes..09..79..06-06..06-04..02
32...Illinois.................06..Yes..07..76..05-07..07-05..02
33...Alabama.............06..No...06..83..10-03..07-05..02
34...Oklahoma...........04..No...09..90..11-02..07-05..02
35...Missouri..............09..Yes..06..73..05-07..07-05..02
36...Iowa St...............08..No...07..77..07-06..07-05..02
37...Arizona St..........09..Yes..07..77..08-05..07-05..02
38...B College...........05..No...06..80..08-04..07-05..02
39...New Mexico.......10..Yes..07..68..07-06..07-05..02
40...Troy St................05..Yes..04..60..04-08..05-03..02
41...Miami Ohio.........07..Yes..07..72..07-05..07-05..02
42...Ohio St...............11..Yes..06..88..13-00..07-06..01
43...Louisiana St.......07..Yes..06..81..08-04..06-05..01
44...Texas Tech.........09..No...05..80..08-05..07-06..01
45...UCLA...................07..No...07..82..07-05..06-05..01
46...Oregon St............09..Yes..06..80..08-04..06-05..01
47...Virginia...............09..Yes..07..78..08-05..07-06..01
48...Virginia Tech......07..Yes..09..86..09-04..07-06..01
49...Rutgers...............07..Yes..08..53..01-11..06-05..01
50...Colorado St........08..Yes..07..78..10-03..07-06..01
51...Rice....................07..Yes..03..63..04-07..06-05..01
52...C Florida............04..Yes..08..70..07-05..06-05..01
53...Idaho..................06..yes..07..58..02-10..06-05..01
54...UL Monroe..........08..Yes..08..52..03-09..06-05..01
55...Wisconsin...........07..No...09..80..07-06..06-06..00
56...Northwestern......07..Yes..09..68..03-09..06-06..00
57...Tennessee..........08..Yes..03..85..08-04..06-06..00
58...Mississippi..........08..Yes..08..77..06-06..06-06..00
59...Nebraska............05..Yes..07..86..07-07..06-06..00
60...Louisville............07..No...05..75..07-05..06-06..00
61...San Diego St......06..Yes..07..66..04-09..06-06..00
62...Wyoming............07..Yes..08..61..02-10..05-05..00
63...Hawaii................07..Yes..07..69..10-03..06-06..00
64...Navy...................07..Yes..06..54..02-10..06-06..00
65...Arkansas............09..Yes..08..80..09-04..06-07..(01)
66...Oregon...............08..Yes..06..82..07-05..05-06..(01)
67...Florida St...........04..Yes..10..91..09-04..06-07..(01)
68...Clemson.............08..Yes..04..78..07-05..05-06..(01)
69...Temple...............05..Yes..04..65..04-08..05-06..(01)
70...Memphis.............04..Yes..08..64..03-09..05-06..(01)
71...UAB....................09..Yes..07..65..05-07..05-06..(01)
72...Buffalo................07..Yes..09..47..01-11..05-06..(01)
73...Bowling Green....06..Yes..08..70..09-03..05-06..(01)
74...C Michigan..........07..Yes..05..57..04-08..05-06..(01)
75...M Tennessee.......05..Yes..08..61..04-08..05-06..(01)
76...Texas..................08..No...08..89..10-02..05-07..(02)
77...Washington.........08..Yes..08..82..07-05..05-07..(02)
78...Stanford..............03..Yes..08..75..02-09..04-06..(02)
79...Wake Forest........03..No...07..73..06-06..04-06..(02)
80...Pittsburgh............08..Yes..06..77..08-04..05-07..(02)
81...TCU.....................04..No...06..74..09-02..04-06..(02)
82...Houston...............05..Yes..05..60..05-07..05-07..(02)
83...Army....................05..Yes..07..52..01-11..04-06..(02)
84...SMU.....................07..Yes..07..58..03-09..05-07..(02)
85...Marshall...............06..No...06..77..10-02..04-06..(02)
86...UL Lafayette........06..No...05..53..03-09..05-07..(02)
87...Utah St.................04..No...07..62..04-07..04-06..(02)
88...Minnesota............07..Yes..09..75..07-05..04-07..(02)
89...Indiana................07..No...07..68..03-09..04-07..(03)
90...Arizona................07..No...06..73..04-08..04-07..(03)
91...Miami...................06..No...07..96..12-00..04-07..(03)
92...Syracuse..............07..No...07..76..04-08..04-07..(03)
93...Utah.....................05..Yes..05..72..05-06..04-07..(03)
94...Tulsa....................09..Yes..08..52..01-11..04-07..(03)
95...Akron...................11..Yes..06..61..04-08..04-07..(03)
96...W Michigan..........05..Yes..05..67..04-08..04-07..(03)
97...Michigan..............07..Yes..06..87..10-03..04-08..(04)
98...Florida.................06..No...03..89..08-04..04-08..(04)
99...Vanderbilt............06..Yes..06..64..02-10..03-07..(04)
100.Texas A&M...........06..Yes..05..79..06-06..04-08..(04)
101.Georgia Tech.......07..Yes..07..80..07-05..04-08..(04)
102.N Carolina............08..Yes..08..73..03-09..04-08..(04)
103.BYU......................05..Yes..10..72..05-07..04-08..(04)
104.Fresno St..............07..Yes..06..74..08-05..04-08..(04)
105.Mississippi St........06..Yes..07..71..03-09..03-08..(05)
106.Kansas..................05..Yes..06..62..02-10..03-08..(05)
107.E Carolina.............08..Yes..05..71..04-08..03-08..(05)
108.UNLV.....................05..No...06..66..05-07..03-08..(05)
109.UTEP.....................08..Yes..06..54..02-10..03-08..(05)
110.S Carolina.............03..No...06..76..05-07..03-09..(06)
111.So Mississippi........05..Yes..08..74..07-05..02-08..(06)
112.Louisiana Tech......06..Yes..04..64..04-08..03-09..(06)
113.E Michigan.............07..No...10..52..03-09..02-08..(06)
114.New Mexico St.......06..Yes..07..63..07-05..03-09..(06)
115.Michigan St............07..Yes..08..74..04-08..02-09..(07)
116.Kent St...................06..Yes..04..54..03-09..01-09..(08)
117.Baylor....................06..Yes..06..60..03-09..01-10..(09)
I realize this list could look totally different for this year but I think it does help to emphasize what we (should) already know; namely, a winning SU record doesn't necessarily correlate into a winning ATS record. To wit, the following 7 teams combined for a SU record of 75-21, but only went 32-56 ATS.
Texas..........10-02.........05-07
TCU.............09-02.........04-06
Marshall......10-02.........04-06
Miami..........12-00.........04-07
Michigan.....10-03.........04-08
Florida........08-04.........04-08
So Miss.......07-05.........02-08
I guess the name of the game is still 'value' no matter how teams actually 'stack up' against each other. In short, (The Facts) minus (perception) = Value. It appears if there is not a significant difference between the two, then there is probably not a lot of value to be found.
If anything, I think the list shows us the game is beatable (you couldn't prove it by me of late) if one could find a way to be consistently going with the ATS winners and/or against the ATS burners (and of course, managing our money correctly...easier said than done).
Legend: Team, RSO-returning starters offense, QB (Y/N), RSD-returning starters defense, SAG - jeff sagarin's opening power rating (USA Today), SUR - straight up record from last year, ATS - spread record from last year, NETATS - ranking by spread record (net ATS wins).
TEAM...............RSO..QB..RSD..SAG...SUR...ATS...NETATS
01...W Virginia........05..Yes..04..77..09-03..09-02..07
02...UConn..............08..Yes..08..58..06-06..09-02..07
03...N Illinois...........07..Yes..06..70..08-04..09-02..07
04...Iowa.................04..No...07..81..11-01..09-03..06
05...Georgia............03..Yes..07..87..12-01..09-03..06
06...Kansas St.........07..Yes..05..90..10-02..08-02..06
07...Bosie St............03..Yes..07..78..11-01..09-03..06
08...Notre Dame......05..Yes..08..83..10-02..09-03..06
09...Auburn.............08..Yes..08..82..08-04..08-03..05
10...N C State..........07..Yes..05..81..10-03..08-03..05
11...Tulane..............09..Yes..03..66..07-05..08-03..05
12...Cincinnati.........05..Yes..04..71..07-06..09-04..05
13...S Florida...........08..No...06..70..09-02..07-02..05
14...San Jose St.......08..Yes..08..64..06-07..09-04..05
15...Toledo...............04..No...08..75..09-04..08-03..05
16...Penn St..............05..Yes..06..83..09-03..08-04..04
17...Kentucky............07..Yes..04..73..07-05..08-04..04
18...So Cal................06..No...06..86..10-02..08-04..04
19...California...........06..No...02..73..07-05..08-04..04
20...Maryland............06..Yes..09..82..10-03..08-04..04
21...Duke...................11..Yes..09..59..02-10..08-04..04
22...Air Force.............07..Yes..06..73..08-04..08-04..04
23...Oklahoma St.......08..Yes..06..74..07-05..07-04..03
24...Colorado.............03..No...06..83..09-04..08-05..03
25...Washington St.....06..No...07..82..10-02..07-04..03
26...Neveda................07..No...10..62..05-07..07-04..03
27...Ohio U.................04..Yes..08..62..04-08..07-04..03
28...Ball St.................05..Yes..07..62..06-06..07-04..03
29...N Texas...............04..Yes..08..65..07-05..07-04..03
30...Arkansas St.........05..Yes..09..53..06-07..07-04..03
31...Purdue................08..Yes..09..79..06-06..06-04..02
32...Illinois.................06..Yes..07..76..05-07..07-05..02
33...Alabama.............06..No...06..83..10-03..07-05..02
34...Oklahoma...........04..No...09..90..11-02..07-05..02
35...Missouri..............09..Yes..06..73..05-07..07-05..02
36...Iowa St...............08..No...07..77..07-06..07-05..02
37...Arizona St..........09..Yes..07..77..08-05..07-05..02
38...B College...........05..No...06..80..08-04..07-05..02
39...New Mexico.......10..Yes..07..68..07-06..07-05..02
40...Troy St................05..Yes..04..60..04-08..05-03..02
41...Miami Ohio.........07..Yes..07..72..07-05..07-05..02
42...Ohio St...............11..Yes..06..88..13-00..07-06..01
43...Louisiana St.......07..Yes..06..81..08-04..06-05..01
44...Texas Tech.........09..No...05..80..08-05..07-06..01
45...UCLA...................07..No...07..82..07-05..06-05..01
46...Oregon St............09..Yes..06..80..08-04..06-05..01
47...Virginia...............09..Yes..07..78..08-05..07-06..01
48...Virginia Tech......07..Yes..09..86..09-04..07-06..01
49...Rutgers...............07..Yes..08..53..01-11..06-05..01
50...Colorado St........08..Yes..07..78..10-03..07-06..01
51...Rice....................07..Yes..03..63..04-07..06-05..01
52...C Florida............04..Yes..08..70..07-05..06-05..01
53...Idaho..................06..yes..07..58..02-10..06-05..01
54...UL Monroe..........08..Yes..08..52..03-09..06-05..01
55...Wisconsin...........07..No...09..80..07-06..06-06..00
56...Northwestern......07..Yes..09..68..03-09..06-06..00
57...Tennessee..........08..Yes..03..85..08-04..06-06..00
58...Mississippi..........08..Yes..08..77..06-06..06-06..00
59...Nebraska............05..Yes..07..86..07-07..06-06..00
60...Louisville............07..No...05..75..07-05..06-06..00
61...San Diego St......06..Yes..07..66..04-09..06-06..00
62...Wyoming............07..Yes..08..61..02-10..05-05..00
63...Hawaii................07..Yes..07..69..10-03..06-06..00
64...Navy...................07..Yes..06..54..02-10..06-06..00
65...Arkansas............09..Yes..08..80..09-04..06-07..(01)
66...Oregon...............08..Yes..06..82..07-05..05-06..(01)
67...Florida St...........04..Yes..10..91..09-04..06-07..(01)
68...Clemson.............08..Yes..04..78..07-05..05-06..(01)
69...Temple...............05..Yes..04..65..04-08..05-06..(01)
70...Memphis.............04..Yes..08..64..03-09..05-06..(01)
71...UAB....................09..Yes..07..65..05-07..05-06..(01)
72...Buffalo................07..Yes..09..47..01-11..05-06..(01)
73...Bowling Green....06..Yes..08..70..09-03..05-06..(01)
74...C Michigan..........07..Yes..05..57..04-08..05-06..(01)
75...M Tennessee.......05..Yes..08..61..04-08..05-06..(01)
76...Texas..................08..No...08..89..10-02..05-07..(02)
77...Washington.........08..Yes..08..82..07-05..05-07..(02)
78...Stanford..............03..Yes..08..75..02-09..04-06..(02)
79...Wake Forest........03..No...07..73..06-06..04-06..(02)
80...Pittsburgh............08..Yes..06..77..08-04..05-07..(02)
81...TCU.....................04..No...06..74..09-02..04-06..(02)
82...Houston...............05..Yes..05..60..05-07..05-07..(02)
83...Army....................05..Yes..07..52..01-11..04-06..(02)
84...SMU.....................07..Yes..07..58..03-09..05-07..(02)
85...Marshall...............06..No...06..77..10-02..04-06..(02)
86...UL Lafayette........06..No...05..53..03-09..05-07..(02)
87...Utah St.................04..No...07..62..04-07..04-06..(02)
88...Minnesota............07..Yes..09..75..07-05..04-07..(02)
89...Indiana................07..No...07..68..03-09..04-07..(03)
90...Arizona................07..No...06..73..04-08..04-07..(03)
91...Miami...................06..No...07..96..12-00..04-07..(03)
92...Syracuse..............07..No...07..76..04-08..04-07..(03)
93...Utah.....................05..Yes..05..72..05-06..04-07..(03)
94...Tulsa....................09..Yes..08..52..01-11..04-07..(03)
95...Akron...................11..Yes..06..61..04-08..04-07..(03)
96...W Michigan..........05..Yes..05..67..04-08..04-07..(03)
97...Michigan..............07..Yes..06..87..10-03..04-08..(04)
98...Florida.................06..No...03..89..08-04..04-08..(04)
99...Vanderbilt............06..Yes..06..64..02-10..03-07..(04)
100.Texas A&M...........06..Yes..05..79..06-06..04-08..(04)
101.Georgia Tech.......07..Yes..07..80..07-05..04-08..(04)
102.N Carolina............08..Yes..08..73..03-09..04-08..(04)
103.BYU......................05..Yes..10..72..05-07..04-08..(04)
104.Fresno St..............07..Yes..06..74..08-05..04-08..(04)
105.Mississippi St........06..Yes..07..71..03-09..03-08..(05)
106.Kansas..................05..Yes..06..62..02-10..03-08..(05)
107.E Carolina.............08..Yes..05..71..04-08..03-08..(05)
108.UNLV.....................05..No...06..66..05-07..03-08..(05)
109.UTEP.....................08..Yes..06..54..02-10..03-08..(05)
110.S Carolina.............03..No...06..76..05-07..03-09..(06)
111.So Mississippi........05..Yes..08..74..07-05..02-08..(06)
112.Louisiana Tech......06..Yes..04..64..04-08..03-09..(06)
113.E Michigan.............07..No...10..52..03-09..02-08..(06)
114.New Mexico St.......06..Yes..07..63..07-05..03-09..(06)
115.Michigan St............07..Yes..08..74..04-08..02-09..(07)
116.Kent St...................06..Yes..04..54..03-09..01-09..(08)
117.Baylor....................06..Yes..06..60..03-09..01-10..(09)
I realize this list could look totally different for this year but I think it does help to emphasize what we (should) already know; namely, a winning SU record doesn't necessarily correlate into a winning ATS record. To wit, the following 7 teams combined for a SU record of 75-21, but only went 32-56 ATS.
Texas..........10-02.........05-07
TCU.............09-02.........04-06
Marshall......10-02.........04-06
Miami..........12-00.........04-07
Michigan.....10-03.........04-08
Florida........08-04.........04-08
So Miss.......07-05.........02-08
I guess the name of the game is still 'value' no matter how teams actually 'stack up' against each other. In short, (The Facts) minus (perception) = Value. It appears if there is not a significant difference between the two, then there is probably not a lot of value to be found.
If anything, I think the list shows us the game is beatable (you couldn't prove it by me of late) if one could find a way to be consistently going with the ATS winners and/or against the ATS burners (and of course, managing our money correctly...easier said than done).

