Essential Rock & Roll Discs

EXTRAPOLATER

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 22, 2001
8,081
137
63
Toronto
Time to put (some of) my energy into something a little more productive.

I am currently working on a book about R&R.
The format is a list of top discs/albums, targetted for 500 (if "Essentials") or 1000 (just "Top").

A very subjective topic. There are already a number of resources that have taken surveys or otherwise tried to rate and list some top discs, but the style and format I'm shooting for should be appealing to the series rock fan (Mr. Hope).

In the introdution I explain why I am sticking to the "modern age" of R&R, which I define as the time of the British invasion in the early 60's, predominantly started by the Stones and Beatles.
Before this time there were plenty of singles, but not much in the way of full albums, and certainly not of the quality that we have seen since the mid-60's (Revolver era and onward).

I hope to keep this thread going for awhile, and I might add some comments or questions if I get the sense that this forum includes many such fans.

Enough for now. I'm dying to see what kind of action I can get here. The following 10 discs are listed just to get the ball rolling, and to give an example of some that WILL crack the (my) top 500; not listed in any order:

Pink Floyd-Dark Side of the Moon ('73)
The Beatles-Abbey Road ('69)
Led Zeppelin IV ('71)
Blind Faith ('69)
Aerosmith-Get Your Wings ('74)
Dire Straits ('80, if memory serves)
Deep Purple-Machine Head ('72)
U2-The Joshua Tree ('87)
Tool-Aenima ('96)
Michael Jackson-Thriller ('82)

--the last one is not meant as a recommendation, by my tastes anyway; defining that disc as R&R is the stretch that I must make to properly complete this project, and to not strictly rely on my own (and others) subjectivity; maybe stir some controversy, who knows.

Full info (like year) is, of course, not needed.
Favorite songs, or whatever reason you like it would be appreciated (killer guitar, drums, vocals, theme, whatever you can provide as your reason for LOVING the disc).

I have to leave it at that and see what develops here - I could sit here writing passionately about the subject for eons, but I'll wait to add more if things get rockin', or if things fizzle.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Everybody's talkin' 'bout the new sound, funny
but it's still rock 'n roll to me
(Billy Joel)
 

gecko

Senior Lurker
Forum Member
Dec 7, 2001
2,469
0
0
parts unknown
The idea of the "concept album" came to be during the Frank Sinatra/Nelson Riddle collaborations for Capitol Records in the mid-to-late '50's. In the Wee Small Hours, Songs for Swingin' Lovers, Come Fly with Me, Only the Lonely and others are classics, each one interwoven with a central theme that runs throughout the disc.


Yup, seen a lot of lists out there touting "the best" or "the top". Definitely very subjective.

"Most popular" and "most influential" are the most objectively measurable in the very least. In addition to yours, how 'bout these 10? (IMO these have certainly stood up to the test over time)


Are You Experienced? - Jimi Hendrix Experience
Led Zeppelin II
What's Goin' On - Marvin Gaye
Eagles' Greatest Hits (vol. 1)
Damn the Torpedoes - Tom Petty & the Hearbreakers
London Calling - The Clash
1999 - Prince
Substance - New Order
It Takes A Nation of Millions - Public Enemy
Nevermind - Nirvana



GL with your efforts! :)
 

EXTRAPOLATER

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 22, 2001
8,081
137
63
Toronto
Couple of interesting preferences so far. I'm not even familiar with Sleater Kinney, but that's why I started the thread: there's probably several good ones that I'll miss out on if my research isn't overkill (like my BB threads):rolleyes:

I'm currently avoiding any type of Greatest Hits discs, save for some comments in the normal studio discs write-up, sometimes suggesting that the G.H. is a comparable alternative to that listed. There are several G.H. that would qualify as classics (e.g Steve Miller Band, Fleetwood Mac, Eagles, CCR, etc.).

I can't resist adding some more of my probables here, and maybe doing so will help others to remember some forgotten faves.

Fleetwood Mac-Rumours
Kyuss-Blues for the Red Sun
Rolling Stones-several...Beggar's Banquet and Let it Bleed are in
CCR-Cosmo's Factory
UFO-Phenomenon
ZZTop-Tres Hombres
Supertramp-Crime of the Century
Jethro Tull-Aqualung
Jane's Addiction-Ritual de lo Habitual
Black Sabbath-self-titled is my fave (LOVE Warning), but Paranoid, aka War Pigs, is probably more of a public fave
Cactus-Restrictions

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mama let that boy play some rock and roll
Jazz is much too crazy he can't play it when he's old
He's too young for the blues
He's still inside his first pair of shoes
(Doucette-Mama Let Him Play)
 

EXTRAPOLATER

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 22, 2001
8,081
137
63
Toronto
WAS thinking about a seperate section just focusing on G.H. discs, but that would get messy the way I'm currently working on things; one could pretty much do what I have in mind and just stick to Greatest Hits ... probably several hundred of them that would qualify for a recommended list.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
I took a look inside your bedroom door
You look so good lying on your bed
Well, I ask you if you wanted any rhythmic love
You say you wanna rock 'n roll instead
(AC/DC-Back in Black-Rock and Roll Ain't Noise Pollution)
 

EXTRAPOLATER

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 22, 2001
8,081
137
63
Toronto
Lookit' all the action here. I start a thread about wanting to kill somebody, and everybody gets rockin'.

Trying to get rockin' here.

10 More

Yes-Fragile
Doobie Brothers-The Captain & Me
Boston-self-titled
King Crimson-In The Court Of The Crimson King
Montrose-self-titled
Nazareth-Razamanaz
The Who-Who's Next
Rush-2112
Steppenwolf-Monster
Humble Pie-Rockin' The Fillmore

The last is the first live I've posted, and I feel that I havta make room on the list for a number of key live discs.
 

g-hawg

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 14, 2001
450
0
0
oakland, CA , USA
A few of my favorites are;

Grand Funk Railroad; E Pluribus Funk (1971)
Chambers Brothers; Time Has Come (1970 ?)
Buddy Miles; Them Changes (1970)

Will think of more but these come to my mind along with most anything that Jimi Hendrix did.
 

gecko

Senior Lurker
Forum Member
Dec 7, 2001
2,469
0
0
parts unknown
keep the lists comin'.... here are 10 more....

keep the lists comin'.... here are 10 more....

FOLK rock, COUNTRY rock, FUNK rock, PUNK rock....all the same as long as it's great music. :)


Bob Dylan - Blonde on Blonde
Jimi Hendrix - Electric Ladyland
Sly & the Family Stone - Stand!
Allman Brothers - Eat a Peach
CCR - Green River
Stevie Wonder - Innervisions
Lynyrd Skynyrd - Second Helping
Neil Young - Rust Never Sleeps (great live disc from the father of grunge)
Ramones - Ramones
Sex Pistols - Never Mind the Bollocks
 

Nole

Registered User
Forum Member
Jan 7, 2002
16,594
209
63
63
Knoxville, Tn USA
My 2 cents:

Frampton Comes Alive

KISS Alive I

Boston (1st album)

Pink Floyd The Wall

Tom Petty Damn the Torpedos

nole
 

EXTRAPOLATER

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 22, 2001
8,081
137
63
Toronto
Rock n' Roll!
Glad I'm gettin' some action now.
A few contributions, including Abraxas, would've been added by me if no one else beat me to it, but there are a number that I am totally unfamiliar with.

As for what I've got to work with, well ... until I picked up my new system about a year(+) ago, I owned just over 800 pieces. The key thing that makes this project possible for me is the ability to download VIRTUALLY ANYTHING that has ever been recorded (at least that would meet my criteria - British invasion+). I have lost track, totally, but my hard drive has been full, backed-up, cleared, then full again many times over. This has made for a wonderful experience, but cable feeds me so fast that I still have not been able to hear everything (surprisingly most, though). Toughest finds so far were things like Dust and Freedom (early '70 bands) but even they succumbed to a search eventually.

I am certainly not going to include anything that I haven't heard. I could just do some crazy consensus of other people's lists, published or not, but that would totally defeat the purpose here as I hope to make this project an enjoyable experience throughout.

I already have several new disc recommendations to work with and I will make the effort to hear, at the very least, any 'recommended' songs from each one. If anyone has used the site allmusic.com, then you are probably aware of the killer assessments and song recommendations there. Mind you, a number of my favorite tracks often get left off of their recommended songs (they use checkmarks), so I should be ambitious enough to score the works, and at least give a quick listen (quick-scan if sleep-inducing) to each track.
That site was actually a major influence on my decision to attempt this project; while the site itself would appear to be enough for many fans, I think that there is still a market for reference books (which I hope it would qualify as), and that people will appreciate the work if it's done right. It's a subject that I'm quite passionate about, so I hope that my writing gets back to the level that it was a year or two ago ... my grammer, spelling, and poetic injustices presently betray my capabilities.

I'll have to provide a write-up for some of the discs here. Maybe see if there is any hope for the project, and maybe receive some criticisms before submitting a project proposal to the proper publishing place. The latter is something that was recommended to me, but I think that even rejection would not prevent me from persuing such pleasure. Presently in the stages of compiling a list, developing a decent rating system (this idea may/should be trashed), and jotting down a few point-form notes about some discs desirability.

10 more sure things (maybe 1000 isn't inconceivable; I'm just not sure if I can title such a volume 'essentials')
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Don McLean-undecided disc W/AMERICAN PIE (maybe stick to a greatest hits, here, as (personally) I can't stand his other tracks)
Queen-A Night At The Opera
Jefferson Airplane-Surrealistic Pillow
Golden Earring-Moontan
Gov't Mule-self-titled
Cream-Disraeli Gears
Derek & The Dominos-Layla And Other Love Songs
Blue Oyster Cult-Agents of Fortune (& probably earlier stuff also)
Masters of Reality-self-titled
Neil Merryweather-Space Rangers

--the last 2 are particularly subjective choices, I'm tempted to submit (just did). No two lists that will be quite the same, and I'm hoping to include many (500-1000 gives me room) that are difficult finds or otherwise have had less public appeal. For me, the goal is to be sincere and passionate in my appraisals, as well as to give some indication of who these oddballs would appeal to (similar artists, themes, raunch-factor, etc.).

Hope my ramblings aren't distracting from the main purpose, but better to put my energy in here than ... ah .... Nevermind.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Our little group has always been
and always will until the end
(Nirvana-Nevermind-Smells Like Teen Spirit)
 

Mr Hockey

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 17, 2003
2,098
0
0
The Smashing Pumpkins: Siamese Dream

The Smashing Pumpkins: Mellon Collie & The Infinite Sadness
 

Chopsticks

Fish Head
Forum Member
Feb 15, 2002
1,459
2
0
52
Arlington, TX (But a Missourian at heart)
Let's See What I Can Come Up With

Let's See What I Can Come Up With

These Are Just Some Of My Favorites (No Specific Genre, just some music I like)...

Journey-Greatest Hits

John Cougar-American Fool

The Cure-Mixed Up

Live-Mental Jewelry

Pat Benatar-Best Shots

Sonic Youth-Goo

Rush-Chronicles

REO Speedwagon-A Decade of Rock And Roll 1970 to 1980

Hash-Hash

Red Hot Chilli Peppers-Mother's Milk

Breathe-All That Jazz

Bodeans-Black and White

Nirvana-Insecticide

The Black Crowes-Shake Your Money Maker
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top