from another cave (IE level quality read imo) .....
NFL '08: Which stats have mattered most?
Without digging any deeper than what you find in the current NFL standings, it?s easy to see that there has been a definitive shift in the NFL season compared to recent years when it comes to which types of teams are enjoying success. For most of this decade, the dominant teams have been those with the best quarterbacks, or those able to best generate big plays through the passing game. In particular, the Pass Yards Per Attempt statistical leaderboard was very telling.
However, it seems that this season, defense has taken center stage. Apparently, teams have taken hold of what the Giants did to the league?s best three passing teams during last year?s playoff surge, and ran with it. The ability to pressure the passer and minimize big plays from an opposing offense has now become paramount.
To validate this theory, I?ve taken on a statistical study analyzing the strengths and weaknesses of the best and worst teams in the league. I call this my Which Stats Matter Most study.
The basics of the analysis are simple, and there are two parts to the study. In the first part, I look at the Top 5 and Bottom 5 teams in a variety of statistical categories and I combine the straight up and ATS won-lost records of the teams. The assumption is that the greater the percentage margin between the top teams and the bottom teams, the more critical that statistical category is to success, and vice versa. The second part of the study takes these same stat categories and summarizes the SU & ATS won-lost records of the teams that had advantages over their opponent in that category heading into any game between Week 2 & 10.
Here are the findings of the 2-part study. Keep in mind that because of the extensive nature in compiling the figures, I was only able to use data that included the Week 10 results. The Week 11 games are not part of either portion.
Top 5/Bottom 5 Teams Compilation
The chart below illustrates the 17 different stat categories I analyzed. They are sorted in order of the margin of ATS won-lost record between the Top 5 teams and Bottom 5 teams combined.
It is interesting to note that five of the Top 7 ranked categories are defense-specific, and one is Turnover Differential. Essentially, it is the physical styles of teams like Tennessee, Pittsburgh, Carolina, and New York that are winning out over the more offensive oriented teams like New Orleans and San Diego. This is clearly a trend to watch the rest of this season and into the coming years. Perhaps we are witnessing an era change in the NFL.
Pre-Game Stat Edges
After analyzing the combined records of the teams ranked highest or lowest in the given stat categories, I went back and determined the records of the teams that had edges in those specific statistics heading into any given game this season. After all, in hindsight it?s easy to say that you should have been backing Tennessee, Baltimore, or the Giants this season, and fading teams like Denver. The tougher job is to pick teams game by game and to use the results you?ve come up with to forecast future games.
In any case, the table below shows the straight up and ATS records of teams that held edges in these stats going into their games. You?ll notice once again that almost all of the most successful angles are either defensive stat edge oriented or fading the opponent with the offensive edge in a specific stat.
In order to put this information to use in the Week 12 NFL board, we can quickly scan the stat pages at a site like *********, sort the teams by whichever category we choose, and then compile the teams. Here are a few samples of what I mean using the results from the table above.
Play on Teams that have a Defensive Yards Per Play edge. (78-50 SU, 71-55 ATS in ?08)
Teams qualifying for Week 12: Pittsburgh, Houston, Buffalo, Tennessee, Miami, Dallas, Tampa Bay, Baltimore, Chicago, Minnesota, Carolina, Oakland, Washington, NY Giants, Indianapolis, Green Bay
Play on Teams that have a Defensive Rush Yards Per Game edge. (83-45 SU, 70-56 ATS in ?08)
Teams qualifying for Week 12: Pittsburgh, Houston, Buffalo, NY Jets, Miami, San Francisco, Tampa Bay, Baltimore, Chicago, Minnesota, Carolina, Denver, Washington, NY Giants, San Diego, New Orleans
Play on Teams that have a Defensive Points Per Game edge. (78-49 SU, 69-56 ATS in ?08)
Teams qualifying for Week 12: Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Buffalo, Tennessee, New England, Dallas, Tampa Bay, Baltimore, Chicago, Jacksonville, Carolina, Oakland, Washington, NY Giants, Indianapolis, Green Bay
Do the same for the lowest rated offensive stat edges and fade those teams the rest of the way. At the very least it will give you a foundation to build your betting tickets upon, with a heavy concentration on what has been working best this season.