I couldn't disagree more. I love lost. Does it always do what I want or expect it too? No. But that's what makes it intriguing. Is dave on the island? I don't think so. Just because he slaps hurley and throws a coconut at him doesn't mean he can't be a figment of hurley's imagination. christ, he jumped off the cliff, you know that wasn't real. Earlier, in the hospital, dave says he's open and they throw the ball to hurley, that was because it was hurley saying it. The two pictures, the one with dave and the one without, there were so many differences is those that you just know they were playing with hurley. I agree with sun tzu that it's all some kind of therapy for them all. Libby wants hurley to change, Hurley associates dave with his not wanting to change subconscious. Dave wants hurley to climb out the window for a cheeseburger and jump off the cliff to wake up. Is hurley even on the island? How the hell should I know? I'm sitting here trying to figure it all out and I'm talking to myself. Am I even here? (I think I'm the one who needs therapy)
was dave on the island? or even in the mental hospital? what about jack's dad or the horse kate saw, I think sawyer saw it too. I don't have the answers, but I'll be watching again next wednesday as always...