miguel cabrera

[shawn555]

The Tigers would have finished fourth in the AL west. :mj07:

I enjoy the the new stats don't matter but the old ones do argument.

 

[Mr. Poon]

Those are insane too. I'm ready for that debate.

There can't be anyone on the 'pro' side for the current voting of them.

Well before I speak too quickly, does Hedge follow baseball?

 

[Trampled Underfoot]

There can't be anyone on the 'pro' side for the current voting of them.

Well before I speak too quickly, does Hedge follow baseball?

I know he strikes out a lot.

 

[the addict]

I enjoy the the new stats don't matter but the old ones do argument.

not at all what I meant.

if thats how it came off I apologize.


i meant that I value the older stats more then the new.

no different then you value the newer stats more then the old.

 

[Cie]

Who the fuck cares if he had some demons? What the fuck does that mean? I heard Trout's dog died yesterday. Does that change your mind?

Next.

First, I do not care for your tone.

Secondly, I am rooting for MC to win. His battle with alcoholism is part of the reason that I am rooting for MC to win.

 

[Mr. Poon]

Didn't King Felix also win or contend for CY recently with a poor record and great numbers. Not sure if he won, but i do know i was rooting for him.

Felix won it the year after Greinke and that 2 year stretch proved people were looking at it a little differently. If I remember right, those 2 had the lowest win totals outside of relievers who have won the award, or pretty close.

Well, there was David Cone for the Royals who had a low win total too. :facepalm:

 

[Trampled Underfoot]

First, I do not care for your tone.

Secondly, I am rooting for MC to win. His battle with alcoholism is part of the reason that I am rooting for MC to win.

I don't care for your attitude either.

It's fine that you are rooting for him but this is a big boy game. I don't care what problems he has.

 

[canuckfan77]

Not sure how miggy overcoming a self inflicted "disease" (alcoholism) even enters consideration

 

[Cie]

Not sure how miggy overcoming a self inflicted "disease" (alcoholism) even enters consideration

It might not come into play in your decision, but it does in mine:0008

 

[the addict]

Not sure how miggy overcoming a self inflicted "disease" (alcoholism) even enters consideration

dont think in anyway was cie meaning that miggy becomes more deserving because he was battling it..


think he simply means he personally wants to see him win it because the guy is relatable to the average joe dealing with regular problems....

 

[Cie]

dont think in anyway was cie meaning that miggy becomes more deserving because he was battling it..


think he simply means he personally wants to see him win it because the guy is relatable to the average joe dealing with regular problems....

Correct. Some folks are so stirred up by this that you would think it is life or death....lol

 

[canuckfan77]

I cannot say either of these men deserve it less than the other. I won't be upset if one wins it over the other. Bottom line is Trout is a better total player than miggy. This award is for the most valuable player, not the most offensive player. All things considered my vote is for Trout.

 

[the addict]

Correct. Some folks are so stirred up by this that you would think it is life or death....lol

i dont get it...


i wonder if everytime someone has a different opinion they instantly become "foolish", or lumped into a group of "some people" :mj07:


would make each day interesting I suppose...




I know one thing, TU , you can spell like a motherfucker....

I can almost gaurantee you won every spelling bee in gradeschool...:toast:

 

[Trampled Underfoot]

i dont get it...


i wonder if everytime someone has a different opinion they instantly become "foolish", or lumped into a group of "some people" :mj07:


would make each day interesting I suppose...




I know one thing, TU , you can spell like a motherfucker....

I can almost gaurantee you won every spelling bee in gradeschool...:toast:

You made a few errors in this masterpiece too.

 

[the addict]

You made a few errors in this masterpiece too.

i was hoping you would be around to correct me...


i hope you dont correct peoples grammar during coversations.


that would make you a very awkward individual...


and once again, you know that they have said in no way does spelling have any direct correlation to a person's IQ....


so just cause you can speell good, doesnt make your dick bigger :toast:

 

[Mr. Poon]

If you could replicate them, would you rather field a team with 9 Mike Trout's, or 9 Miggy Cabrera's? Just another way to think about the "new aged" stats vs. winning the triple crown.

 

[the addict]

If you could replicate them, would you rather field a team with 9 Mike Trout's, or 9 Miggy Cabrera's? Just another way to think about the "new aged" stats vs. winning the triple crown.

trout.

i dunno if he can field a ground ball..

or pitch...



but i would pick him for sure...

 

[shawn555]

trout.

i dunno if he can field a ground ball..

or pitch...



but i would pick him for sure...

:facepalm:

 

[the addict]

if that means I would appreciate the WAR stat,

then I apologize. maybe I dont truley understand the importance of it...maybe I shouldve looked into more before...






i dunno i just think miggy should win....dude lead the league in homers/rbis/average...


i mean he had more hits per at bat then trout,

that has to count for something doesnt it...

 

[Cie]

If you could replicate them, would you rather field a team with 9 Mike Trout's, or 9 Miggy Cabrera's? Just another way to think about the "new aged" stats vs. winning the triple crown.

i think mt is better, so i would go with mt. still want to vote for mc, though.

anyway, the winner of this hypo game would probably be the better pitcher of the 2:0008