Take your pick then....
Brett Basanez QB Carolina Panthers
Charlie Batch QB Pittsburgh Steelers
Drew Bledsoe QB Dallas Cowboys
Kyle Boller QB Baltimore Ravens
Brooks Bollinger QB Minnesota Vikings
Todd Bouman QB Green Bay Packers
Shane Boyd QB Arizona Cardinals
Tom Brady QB New England Patriots
Drew Brees QB New Orleans Saints
Aaron Brooks QB Oakland Raiders
Mark Brunell QB Washington Redskins
Marc Bulger QB St. Louis Rams
Jason Campbell QB Washington Redskins
Lang Campbell QB Cleveland Browns
David Carr QB Houston Texans
Matt Cassel QB New England Patriots
Kellen Clemens QB New York Jets
Kerry Collins QB Tennessee Titans
Todd Collins QB Washington Redskins
Brodie Croyle QB Kansas City Chiefs
Jay Cutler QB Denver Broncos
Jake Delhomme QB Carolina Panthers
Koy Detmer QB Philadelphia Eagles
Trent Dilfer QB San Francisco 49ers
Ken Dorsey QB Cleveland Browns
Brett Favre QB Green Bay Packers
A.J. Feeley QB Philadelphia Eagles
Ryan Fitzpatrick QB St. Louis Rams
Gus Frerotte QB St. Louis Rams
Charlie Frye QB Cleveland Browns
Jeff Garcia QB Philadelphia Eagles
David Garrard QB Jacksonville Jaguars
Bruce Gradkowski QB Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Quinn Gray QB Jacksonville Jaguars
Trent Green QB Kansas City Chiefs
David Greene QB Seattle Seahawks
Brian Griese QB Chicago Bears
Rex Grossman QB Chicago Bears
Joey Harrington QB Miami Dolphins
Matt Hasselbeck QB Seattle Seahawks
Tim Hasselbeck QB New York Giants
Shaun Hill QB San Francisco 49ers
Kelly Holcomb QB Buffalo Bills
Damon Huard QB Kansas City Chiefs
Tarvaris Jackson QB Minnesota Vikings
Brad Johnson QB Minnesota Vikings
Doug Johnson QB Cincinnati Bengals
Jon Kitna QB Detroit Lions
Matt Leinart QB Arizona Cardinals
Cleo Lemon QB Miami Dolphins
Jared Lorenzen QB New York Giants
J.P. Losman QB Buffalo Bills
Eli Manning QB New York Giants
Peyton Manning QB Indianapolis Colts
Ingle Martin QB Green Bay Packers
Jamie Martin QB New Orleans Saints
Shane Matthews QB Miami Dolphins
Josh McCown QB Detroit Lions
Luke McCown QB Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Steve McNair QB Baltimore Ravens
Craig Nall QB Buffalo Bills
John Navarre QB Arizona Cardinals
Dan Orlovsky QB Detroit Lions
Kyle Orton QB Chicago Bears
Carson Palmer QB Cincinnati Bengals
Chad Pennington QB New York Jets
Jake Plummer QB Denver Broncos
Quinton Porter QB Houston Texans
Casey Printers QB Kansas City Chiefs
Patrick Ramsey QB New York Jets
Tim Rattay QB Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Philip Rivers QB San Diego Chargers
Ben Roethlisberger QB Pittsburgh Steelers
Tony Romo QB Dallas Cowboys
Matt Schaub QB Atlanta Falcons
D.J. Shockley QB Atlanta Falcons
Alex Smith QB San Francisco 49ers
Jim Sorgi QB Indianapolis Colts
Brian St. Pierre QB Pittsburgh Steelers
Vinny Testaverde QB New England Patriots
Marques Tuiasosopo QB Oakland Raiders
Bradlee Van Pelt QB Houston Texans
Michael Vick QB Atlanta Falcons
Billy Volek QB San Diego Chargers
Seneca Wallace QB Seattle Seahawks
Andrew Walter QB Oakland Raiders
Kurt Warner QB Arizona Cardinals
Chris Weinke QB Carolina Panthers
Charlie Whitehurst QB San Diego Chargers
Anthony Wright QB Cincinnati Bengals
Vince Young QB Tennessee Titans
I could put bledsoe in front of him, when he was in his prime he was just as good if not better than Manning. There are a few others as well.
Warner would be another good choice when he was in his prime.
kneifl
