Rating the rookies

the addict

BI-WINNING
Forum Member
Oct 9, 2009
13,034
116
0
40
PA proud
Only the rookie qbs of course.....alfred morris been best rookie to this point at any other position...

As far as their teams succes, I would say the dolphins and the colts are in the best hands....all the teams with rookie qbs are improved, but I would say its got to be the colts or the dolphins...
Both 4-3 going into yesterday and now colts are game ahead so I guess I would say the colts to this point....They went from worst team in league last year to a playoffs...wilson and seattle are winning, but he has a much better defense and isn't asked to do as much...

As far as just grading the quarterback play, I would go as follows:


1. Luck. No question he is the class of the class.

2. Tannenhill. Matched luck yesterday as far as good smart football, and continues everyweek to improve. He is going to be a really really good player.

3. Wilson. Kid is a winner. Really minimized mistakes. I see this seattle team being like sanfran in years to come. A qb who doesn't mess up, a rb who can pound it, and a defense that is elite...

4. Rg3. I'm sure most will critisize me for this, but way to inconsistent to this point, and does not understand how to avoid the big hits...big future, but think the other 3 have been better thus far.

5. Weeden. Any other team besides the browns and he wouldn't even be a starter right now. Has all the tools and smarts, but think he would have benefited to sit behind someone like peyton for a year. Sometimes life ain't fair.




The rest- think cousins from washington could be a viable starter in this league...kid in denver from zona st is in a good spot to learn from the best.....

Really think cousins had bad break going to wash where they invested so much into another rookie....he is legit...
 

the addict

BI-WINNING
Forum Member
Oct 9, 2009
13,034
116
0
40
PA proud
Forgot about him....

Id still take morris to this point...love how he runs...

Martin can do it all tho as far as catching/runinng/blocking....will be elite back no doubt
 

bleedingpurple

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 23, 2008
22,494
304
83
52
Where it is real F ing COLD
This thread pisses me off cause last year was the years went for a Rookie QB and they all suck. Too bad they didn't draft a position player and went with QB this year. Vines are fucked
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top