Take your pick

[the addict]

Curious to see what the madjack community thinks of this hypothetical





If you are the NFL commish, and you have to pick one draft class of QBS to be the face and the future of your billion dollar industry



do you want the 2004 class, or this years class?


of course assuming they were all the same age and all right out of college.





2004:

BEN ROETHLISBERGER

PHILLIP RIVERS

ELI MANNING

MATT SCHAUB (unfairly is never talked about here)

JP LOSSMAN





2012:

ANDREW LUCK

RG3

RYAN TANNENHILL

RUSSELL WILSON

BRANDON WEEDEN







I have a hard time believing that there will be more superbowl rings from the 2012 class then compared to the 2004 class......


2 for ben

2 for eli

thats 4....




curious to see who people think is the best...

 

[the addict]

give me this years if it was right out of college...


this years class has more potential then any class ever..







in hindsite, of course id take 2004, but I think this years class will be more succesful regarding stats and wins, just not superbowls

 

[hogman14]

2000:
Tom B

3 for him.
5 appearances. :0008

 

[MonsterNco]

2012 looks better at this point compared to where the 2004 class was. I think Luck in 20 years will be looked at as the best of both classes.

2004 class has played in 5 Superbowls and number has a good chance to go up this year. So a big up hill battle for 2012 there.

I would take the sure thing right now with 2004 after all that.

 

[the addict]

Are there any other big names from the 2000 draft at qb position?



And agree monster, andrew luck will go down as one of the best

 

[MonsterNco]

2000 Pennington and Bulger to go with Brady. Not much after that.

 

[eSKayT]

Jp losman can eat sh*t

 

[poolplayer8888]

I will say 1983 with Elway, Marino and J. Kelly.....

 

[Juu3]

yeah I like the '83 class...if that's the actual...but

Big Ben and company by far to answer your question!

 

[the addict]

Anything involving rivers,


Ill go the other way....

Eeeeeeesh

 

[Zamo]

Rivers sucks!!

2012 class will rival 83 guys IMO much ore than 2004

This years class is going to be AMAZING and do not forget about one Brock Osweiler who will come into his own in several years and be a force!! Just you watch....

Andrew Luck if he stays healthy......DOMINATION, Tannehill is for real, Wilson is real strong, Weeden is turning corner but who knows with him, RG3 is a beast and Osweiler will be the truth! HA!!

 

[the addict]

Cousins from mich st will be a good starter in this league


Shame is he is a rookie behind a rookie with rg3


He will get traded or go somewhere and have a chance to play



I like him......a lot