Nick-
I diasagree with your statement: "yet you guys are calling this a fluke under"
No one called it a fluke! But there are numbers that may be used in someone's handicapping arsenal that fully expects a team to hit their averages when it comes to stats. This may not be your style or one of the checklist items you use when handicapping a game, some use computer simulations, other use systems., some use line moves, blah, blah. Not one of which is technically right or wrong, it depends on what works for you and your handicapping style. I happen to use this information when handicapping and it was one of the reasons I played the game.
Now here is some of that info that I mentioned in my post that failed me in this game although I specifically only mentioned FT's:
IF Dallas or Atlanta hit their averages (These are the averages of Dallas on the road, and Atlanata at home, this game easily covers not only the posted 198 line, but the 198.5 I got, or the 200 BTJ got. (We are not dealing with great defensive teams here, so averages can be expected, and not a reach.
For the year:
Dallas : 3 pt FG% (6-20 31.9%) FT % (18-23 79.5%)
Atlanta: 3 pt FG% (4-12 33.2%) FT % (19-24 76.6%)
I am rarely insulted, but in this case I took I felt it was condescending to the point where I felt I should reply. You seem rather intelligent so you will understand this. You are neither the expert in handicapping, nor the one to be dispensing advice. It would be much different if you came on and dispensed your numerical information as a "did you know" rather than a "This is why" approach. But I may be in the minority in that fact, and I am ok with that.
As for the point you cannot make money if the line moves against you? I guess it all depends on what the individual handicapped it at. It is always important to shop, but I bet into a number whether it moves or not depending on what I see happening. But in your post you made the point: "Forget handicapping and number of shots and shooting percentages and all of that. You can't make money in this business if you consistently bet lines that have moved against you." I don't believe in that, you are a number's guy, where is the supporting data that if a line moves against you, you are on the wrong side?
I wish you well on your next wager, but remember everyone has a different way of handicapping, everyone has a different point of view, embrace it, challenge it if you want but, NEVER put words into my mouth! ( I say this after reviewing the post I was the only one that mentioned to BTJ that it was a good play. So when you mentioned "You Guys" I assumed it as BTJ and myself.)
TSI