Indians lead series 3-2
Indians lead series 3-2
Game #6
Carmona @ Schilling
Red Sox 56% (-127)even
under 9.5 54% (-117)even --ump DeMuth is even/slightly over (more overs than unders in 4 of the past 5 years and this year had a K% under 62 for the season; call was under the 9.5 at 57% before a 3% pena for DeMuth; really not much value here regardless)
I'm giving a small edge to the Indians pitching. A slightly larger edge is given to the Red Sox hitting. The determined edge is primarily home-field advantage and a very small momentum factor.
Carmona faced the Bosox twice last season, both times for very short relief appearances at Fenway Park, and he took the loss each time despite only lasting for an inning combined between the two games. 2006 was a bust for Carmona, as his 1-10 record and 5.42 era will attest. In one meeting with the 'Sox this season, at home on July 25th, he outduelled Josh Beckett and picked up the W in a 1-0 game, allowing 4 hits and 2 walks while striking out 6. That game concluded a sensational run by Fausto where he won 5 straight decisions, looking real good in the process. Carmona tossed 9 brilliant innings against the Yankees in game #2 of their series at home. In game #2 of their current series, on the road, Carmona was not very effective as he allowed 4 hits, 5 walks, and 4 earned runs over his 4 innings pitched. For the regular season, Carmona's era was better on the road (2.80 vs 3.32 at home) though his whip and BAA were slightly higher on the road. He went 9-4 in 16 road starts this season. Indians have great middle relief but closer Borowski isn't the greatest.
Schilling faced the Indians once during the regular season, at home on May 28th, and got the W in a 5-3 decision over Cliff Lee; Curt threw 7 solid innings, allowing 6 hits and 1 earned run while walking none and striking out 10. He's 2-2 with a 3.79 era in his career against the Indians during the regular season. At home this season, Schilling was 4-3 with a 4.06 era. He was pretty solid from the middle part of August to the end of the regular season, though the Bosox lost 4 of his last 5 regular season starts, with Curt going 1-3 over that time. Schilling looked great in game #3 of the Angels series, shutting them down for 7 innings. Schilling was horrible in game #2 of their current series, allowing 9 hits, including 2 homers (Peralta & Sizemore), and 5 earnies over 4.2 innings pitched. Bosox pen is, arguably, the best left in these playoffs; Papelbon is a solid closer.
Indians .760 OPS vs R during the regular season
Red Sox .808 OPS vs R RS
Indians .749 OPS on the road RS
Red Sox .844 OPS at home RS
Indians hitting .284 vs R last 10 games
Red Sox hitting .257 vs R last 10 games
(for a change, these "last 10 games" numbers are up-to-date)
The following 4 numbers are also up-to-date, and might keep me off the under:
--Indians .841 OPS this postseason in 9 games
--Red Sox .847 OPS this postseason in 8 games
--Indians .758 OPS this series
--Red Sox .838 OPS this series
Both clubs hit well in their first series'.
The discrepancy in the current series is due to the Bosox having 5 more walks (21 to 16) and they're also hitting 27 points higher (.285 to .258). The power numbers for this series are quite similar, with both clubs having 7 homers while the Indians have 10 doubles and the Bosox have 9 doubles and a triple.
Also of note is the Indians striking out 54 times while the Bosox hitters have only fanned 31 times.
Indians 29-28 on the road to R RS
Red Sox 39-22 at home to R RS
This is a very tough game to call. Neither starting pitcher performed anywhere near their capabilities in the game #2 meeting. It's difficult to say which of these starters will make the necessary adjustments to improve on their horrible performances; Schilling has more experience but Carmona, I'd say, has the better stuff at this stage of their careers; I was thinking that Schilling might have MORE trouble making the proper adjustments as his trouble in game #2 was that he could get hardly anything past the Indians hitters?his trouble was that he was consistently being beaten on his fastball; Carmona, on the other hand, had difficulty locating his stuff and really wasn't finding the strike zone on a consistent bases?I was thinking that, like Sabathia in his second go against the Bosox, Carmona just simply needs to be more aggressive and go right after hitters?maybe an adjustment that is easier than trying to fool the hitters that you weren't fooling just a few days earlier; I've decided that that angle is, perhaps, a mistake for a couple of reasons; first, Sabathia got his second start at home, making it much easier to relax and just pitch his game; Carmona will, again, be starting on the road and the raucious Red Sox crowd may very well get under his skin, again causing him to lose some of his control; secondly, Sabathia walked only 1.4 batters per 9 innings pitched during the regular season so the control problems seemed very out of character for him and something that he would likely improve on?Carmona walked just over 3.5 batters per 9 innings pitched during the regular season so his control, this season, was not as good as C.C.s. Bottom line is that I am still having difficulty determining who will make the necessary adjustments to improve upon their dreadful performance. That preceeding convoluted argument probably doesn't help too much. How about other angles?I can't give too much credit to the Bosox for their newfound momentum, as it looked as if the Bosox had some heading into game #2 while it appeared as if the Indians had some heading into game #5. Both of today's starters were great in the previous series, but neither carried that over into this current series. Schilling didn't walk a batter in game #2 (3 K's) but was easily hittable. Carmona's troubles were more a matter of not being able to find the strike zone. If you have an idea of which of those two problems is more easily correctable then you've got a better read on this match than I have, and you'd then probably have a good idea of who should win. If I had to play a side then I'd likely try the Indians, despite the system call; a good reason for me to simply pass. The following score prediction is simply a reflection of the system call, though I have very little confidence in it for this game #6. Wishy-freakin'-Washy?can't be helped?this game is a bitch.
Predicted score: Red Sox 5 Indians 4
Plays pending.
GL