Those fuckers tried to pull some shit over on you but since you bulked, they backed off real quick. Crooked fucks!
Anyone know anything about car repair?
- Thread starter Senor Capper
- Start date
Those fuckers tried to pull some shit over on you but since you bulked, they backed off real quick. Crooked fucks!
Because the water pump is run off of the timing belt. It's common practice to replace it when the timing belt is done. It saves from having to do the same labor twice when the waterpump does go out.
First off a few questions.
Did the car run fine before you took it to the mechanic?
Does the engine have a miss as well as the noise? Listen to the tail pipe for a sucking noise while idling.
The mechanic was correct in asking you to replace the parts during the repair. If the water pump was to fail at later date you would be changing the timing belt as well again. That part he got right.
The repair procedure and his mechanical skills is what I question.
My take:
It sounds like they miss timed the engine when they installed the timing belt and started the vehicle. On certain engines this can cause the valve to hit the top of the piston damaging the valve.
What I mean by miss timed is that the belt could have been one to two teeth off when it was installed. Once the mechanic started the engine it would have instantly damaged the valve.
Again I am not sure on this year of engine. Your dealer would know though. Also since your car is going to the dealer ask them to chk for the timing belt being properly installed and timed. Request pictures if not. Now this may not be to easy identify. The mechanic could have realized that he fucked up and then went back and properly timed the engine to cover his mistake. Hoping that somehow it would fix the issue. I am just giving possible scenarios here. You will know more once the engine is torn down again.
I have seen this happen many a times to customers. I used to fix idiots mistakes all the time. Had the mechanic taken the proper time to rotate the engine by hand after installation and had he rechecked the alignment then this could have been avoided if that is the issue now.
Valves just don't bend on there own. They have to strike something from mechanical failure or improper repair procedure.
If the valve is bent you are looking at a very costly repair well over 1,000 dollars I would imagine. The cylinder head is likely damage as well. The valve guide and seat will need machined or replaced. The cylinder head could be damaged or cracked as well from the bent valve. If that is the case then the repair will be even more.
Oil is not the issue here. Nor is it a recall issue.This guy sounds like an idiot and is not being truthful. I don't care what oil you use as long as it meets the manufacturers requirement and you service it at the proper interval your engine will last for well over 100,000+ miles.
You have been had by a shade tree mechanic would be my best guess.
When it comes to automotive repair; cheaper is not always better. Always ask for an ASE certified mechanic. If the shop does not have one move on to the next.
Hope this helps.
Did the car run fine before you took it to the mechanic?
Does the engine have a miss as well as the noise? Listen to the tail pipe for a sucking noise while idling.
The mechanic was correct in asking you to replace the parts during the repair. If the water pump was to fail at later date you would be changing the timing belt as well again. That part he got right.
The repair procedure and his mechanical skills is what I question.
My take:
It sounds like they miss timed the engine when they installed the timing belt and started the vehicle. On certain engines this can cause the valve to hit the top of the piston damaging the valve.
What I mean by miss timed is that the belt could have been one to two teeth off when it was installed. Once the mechanic started the engine it would have instantly damaged the valve.
Again I am not sure on this year of engine. Your dealer would know though. Also since your car is going to the dealer ask them to chk for the timing belt being properly installed and timed. Request pictures if not. Now this may not be to easy identify. The mechanic could have realized that he fucked up and then went back and properly timed the engine to cover his mistake. Hoping that somehow it would fix the issue. I am just giving possible scenarios here. You will know more once the engine is torn down again.
I have seen this happen many a times to customers. I used to fix idiots mistakes all the time. Had the mechanic taken the proper time to rotate the engine by hand after installation and had he rechecked the alignment then this could have been avoided if that is the issue now.
Valves just don't bend on there own. They have to strike something from mechanical failure or improper repair procedure.
If the valve is bent you are looking at a very costly repair well over 1,000 dollars I would imagine. The cylinder head is likely damage as well. The valve guide and seat will need machined or replaced. The cylinder head could be damaged or cracked as well from the bent valve. If that is the case then the repair will be even more.
Oil is not the issue here. Nor is it a recall issue.This guy sounds like an idiot and is not being truthful. I don't care what oil you use as long as it meets the manufacturers requirement and you service it at the proper interval your engine will last for well over 100,000+ miles.
You have been had by a shade tree mechanic would be my best guess.
When it comes to automotive repair; cheaper is not always better. Always ask for an ASE certified mechanic. If the shop does not have one move on to the next.
Hope this helps.
Last edited:
I just read the entire post and seen where they are making the repair and are eating the cost. This should be the last time you do business with dumb and dumber.
Do yourself a favor and find reputable mechanic in your area. It will save you $$ in the end.
A top notch mechanic will not pressure you into making unnecessary repairs. He should provide you with a deatiled quote and show you the parts replaced that you are paying for.
With today's technology he could also provide you with photo's of repairs as they are being made.
Customers are willing to visit a top notch mechanic each and every time if they find someone they can trust and who is upfront with them.
Your mechanic should inspect your vehicle during each service and provide you with feedback on brake pad wear, tire wear and scheduled services needed at future dates. This saves you from possible breakdowns and keeps you on the raod when needed. If repairs are needed, always ask for a detailed quote and to see the parts that where replaced. Remember you are buying the parts!A top notch mechanic should always be willing to show you items replaced and willing to discuss repairs made. This not only shows he knows what he is talking about it also shows he cares about your business.
You would be surprised how many times people are ripped off by aut repair shops not installing parts they say they replaced.
Your mechanic is like a Dr. he keeps the second most important thing in your life running. Your Car. Your family is first.
I had many customers who only allowed me to service and repair their vehicle. This came from quality work and honesty. Something many lack in today's society and business industry.
Do yourself a favor and find reputable mechanic in your area. It will save you $$ in the end.
A top notch mechanic will not pressure you into making unnecessary repairs. He should provide you with a deatiled quote and show you the parts replaced that you are paying for.
With today's technology he could also provide you with photo's of repairs as they are being made.
Customers are willing to visit a top notch mechanic each and every time if they find someone they can trust and who is upfront with them.
Your mechanic should inspect your vehicle during each service and provide you with feedback on brake pad wear, tire wear and scheduled services needed at future dates. This saves you from possible breakdowns and keeps you on the raod when needed. If repairs are needed, always ask for a detailed quote and to see the parts that where replaced. Remember you are buying the parts!A top notch mechanic should always be willing to show you items replaced and willing to discuss repairs made. This not only shows he knows what he is talking about it also shows he cares about your business.
You would be surprised how many times people are ripped off by aut repair shops not installing parts they say they replaced.
Your mechanic is like a Dr. he keeps the second most important thing in your life running. Your Car. Your family is first.
I had many customers who only allowed me to service and repair their vehicle. This came from quality work and honesty. Something many lack in today's society and business industry.
Last edited:
