You are correct, Girardi should have challenged it, replay was pretty clear as to what happened.
I got no dog in this fight, but I do hate to see horrible calls decide games.
Yep, replay zoomed in, slow motion, no sound lol
Umpire gets none of that discretion. Gotta love experts who've never done what they're critiquing.
This wasn't your standard runner thrown out at the bag missed call. You're asking an umpire to base a decision off sound over eyes when there's prob 45k going nuts at the time.
This is about 1% umpire fault, and 99% Girardi fault.