Peyton Manning
- Thread starter Blitz
- Start date
opcorn2
peyton really gets around...I`m pretty sure we saw him when we visited easter island.....
/google it......:grins:
/google it......:grins:
This is why Rahim Moore should get half of Flacco's multi million dollar contract. If the doooosh makes a play, the Ravens don't win a ring and Flacco is considered an average qb at best.
Something is wrong with Peyton. I'm wondering if his neck is bothering him. Yes, they had success running the ball in a few games after losing to STL. But He can't get passes to some players (not to discount the Indy D, as it's been awesome today,) and some passes not pulled in, but he doesn't look crisp. And that last series where they started to get a rhthym, once they got a first down, went back to the run, and the drive stalled.
I think Peyton is tired--his neck or arm, that is. Just don't see that same umph under his passes.
I felt Denver was making a mistake relying on the run as much as they did, and now, when it counts, it has come back to haunt them.
Would rather have had Denver vs Pats instead of Indy. Still think Pats win, but believe Colts more difficult to beat. We shall see. Kinda hard to watch this game.
I think Peyton is tired--his neck or arm, that is. Just don't see that same umph under his passes.
I felt Denver was making a mistake relying on the run as much as they did, and now, when it counts, it has come back to haunt them.
Would rather have had Denver vs Pats instead of Indy. Still think Pats win, but believe Colts more difficult to beat. We shall see. Kinda hard to watch this game.
Sad way for Peyton to go out but it happens. def had no sacks I think Peyton was hurt the last 6 weeks and they kept it under wraps--I am sure if true it will come out tomorrow
- Mar 19, 2006
- 38,645
- 557
- 113
- 75
it was painful to watch these guys too
Willie Mays
Mickey Mantle
Bruce Smith
Emmitt Smith
Gordie Howe
Y A Title
and 20 more if I want to think that hard
these I saw.
most don't get the trophy and the easy chair the same day
we appreciate the gazillion hours they put in.
thank them for the entertainment..
and try to realize it ain't really fair to downgrade and berate someone who gives what the folks give.
I've said a lot before but its apples and oranges.
Here is what I see with Peyton's legacy. For one, yes, he should have won more playoff games. But...he rarely played in wildcard games...which would have been against "easier" competition...to get that "first round win"
Also, he played on finesse teams. Nothing wrong with that but for some reason the NFL has to referee differently in the playoffs. So his receivers get molested and no call while he never had a good defense, at least at Indy...and they are of no help.
Meanwhile, a guy like Brady had really good defense over the years and also really physical defense that got away with murder in the playoffs. Hell, throw in Spygate and its no wonder they won.
I can draw up all kinds of great offensive plays...but if DB's are allowed to grab and hold my receivers, they aren't going to work. That's the downfall of Peyton's legacy. I'm sure many will disagree...especially Patriot fans who see nothing wrong with cheating. But if the game was called like it should be, Peyton would have about 4 rings. But the playoffs are different....its about "defense" and "toughness"...and "cheating"...lol the league is a joke...proven by the catch that never was today. I'm so tired of the NFL.
Here is what I see with Peyton's legacy. For one, yes, he should have won more playoff games. But...he rarely played in wildcard games...which would have been against "easier" competition...to get that "first round win"
Also, he played on finesse teams. Nothing wrong with that but for some reason the NFL has to referee differently in the playoffs. So his receivers get molested and no call while he never had a good defense, at least at Indy...and they are of no help.
Meanwhile, a guy like Brady had really good defense over the years and also really physical defense that got away with murder in the playoffs. Hell, throw in Spygate and its no wonder they won.
I can draw up all kinds of great offensive plays...but if DB's are allowed to grab and hold my receivers, they aren't going to work. That's the downfall of Peyton's legacy. I'm sure many will disagree...especially Patriot fans who see nothing wrong with cheating. But if the game was called like it should be, Peyton would have about 4 rings. But the playoffs are different....its about "defense" and "toughness"...and "cheating"...lol the league is a joke...proven by the catch that never was today. I'm so tired of the NFL.
Thanks dude. I know my post might not be popular with some but I admire what Peyton has done in his career and just can't stand to see different rules put in place when it comes to the playoffs.
I also love Marvin Harrison and I've seen him and all their receivers just not able to do anything b/c they are grabbed/held/molested the entire game...and its shown as if the defenders are "tough" and they are "letting them play"
Never been a Colt fan (though I probably would have been one if I was alive during the Unitas days) but I do love/admire what Manning can and has done and just don't understand the way ref's call the game in the postseason.
Best 2 players of all-time to me....#1 Jerry Rice. #2 Peyton Manning.
I also love Marvin Harrison and I've seen him and all their receivers just not able to do anything b/c they are grabbed/held/molested the entire game...and its shown as if the defenders are "tough" and they are "letting them play"
Never been a Colt fan (though I probably would have been one if I was alive during the Unitas days) but I do love/admire what Manning can and has done and just don't understand the way ref's call the game in the postseason.
Best 2 players of all-time to me....#1 Jerry Rice. #2 Peyton Manning.
Coming from a Chiefs lifetime fan, Peyton is/was one of the best ever. Too bad he did not win more playoff games than he did. It still does not take away from how fantastic he really is. Should have won the Heisman, but Woodson did. He got screwed in my opinion. Hashy, good to see you. Good luck to all. We have a lot of NCAA basketball yet to win. Lets go.
- Sep 1, 2012
- 10,674
- 1,245
- 113
Hard to look at someone's pro career based on numbers. Based on everything you said Dan Marino is the best QB ever. Look at the numbers he produced with zero running game and Duper and Clayton only for part of his career. Peyton is a top #10 QB but no where near the top 5. Just my opinion. Rodgers and Brady are in a different class than Manning. Look at Eli he is no where near a top 10 QB but has 2 rings.
Trent Dilfer...The list goes on. Peyton goes down in the top 10. I would take Rodgers or Brady anyday over Peyton. That's not to say I don't think he is amazing with an amazing career.
Its tough to say where I'd take just about anyone. Look at Montana....I'd take him first...except that he also benefited from...good god...coaching way ahead of its time...Jerry f'n Rice...talent everywhere on offense and defense....but at the same time Montana was still amazing.
Brady has 3 Super Bowls...but, the tuck rule...that's a bullshit title. That was a fumble and Raiders could have run clock out. Spygate....come on, they knew the plays. Brady is damn good but I can't put him too high with all that bullshit.
Even Manning....incredible talent on offense with the Colts. There's a reason the defense sucked....its b/c they spent all the money on offense. My main beef with it is that all that money on offense got cheated b/c teams (mainly the Patriots) got away with murder on those talented finesse receivers in the playoffs.
Colts set their team up to be powerful on offense and crappy on defense. So I have no problem judging Manning on that. But they won like hell in regular season and then in playoffs, refs swallow whistle, and Colts lose b/c of it. Not fair. Patriots are "blue collar" "cold weather" "tough" "defensive" and ref's/league let them get away with murder...throw in bitch brady and also tuck rule bullshit...yeah 3 titles. Its a phony league and if nothing else I love the other Manning and the Giants for at least preventing that pussy from getting 2 more rings.
Brady has 3 Super Bowls...but, the tuck rule...that's a bullshit title. That was a fumble and Raiders could have run clock out. Spygate....come on, they knew the plays. Brady is damn good but I can't put him too high with all that bullshit.
Even Manning....incredible talent on offense with the Colts. There's a reason the defense sucked....its b/c they spent all the money on offense. My main beef with it is that all that money on offense got cheated b/c teams (mainly the Patriots) got away with murder on those talented finesse receivers in the playoffs.
Colts set their team up to be powerful on offense and crappy on defense. So I have no problem judging Manning on that. But they won like hell in regular season and then in playoffs, refs swallow whistle, and Colts lose b/c of it. Not fair. Patriots are "blue collar" "cold weather" "tough" "defensive" and ref's/league let them get away with murder...throw in bitch brady and also tuck rule bullshit...yeah 3 titles. Its a phony league and if nothing else I love the other Manning and the Giants for at least preventing that pussy from getting 2 more rings.
Very funny stuff! Peyton one of the all time greats. Brady one of the all time greats. Brady benefited from better coaches throughout his career. I am thankful I got to see both of them play.
Peyton Manning is the most overrated QB (which is to say probably the most overrated player) in NFL history.
1998 Throws 28 INTs during regular season as team misses playoffs.
1999: Throws 0 TDs in 42 attempts in one & done elimination loss to Titans.
2000: Throws 1 TD in one & done elimination loss to Dolphins, giving them only playoff victory of decade.
2001: Throws 23 INTs during regular season as team misses playoffs.
2002: Throws 0 TDs and 2 INTs in 41-0 one & done elimination loss to the 9-7 Jets.
2003: Throws 4 INTs in AFC Championship game in elimination loss to Patriots. "MVP" year
2004: Throws 0 TDs and 1 INT in AFC Championship game in elimination loss to Patriots. "MVP" year
2005: Throws 1 TD at home in a one & done elimination loss to the Steelers, after a 14-2 season
2006: Throws 3 TDs / 7 INTs with 70.5 QB rating while being carried by his defense and Adam Vinatieri to his only SB.
2007: Throws 6 INTs in reglular season loss to Norv Turner then proceeds to be eliminated in one & done playoff game by same team.
2008: Throws 1 TD against Norv Turner's 31st ranked pass defense in a first round elimination loss to 8-8 Chargers. "MVP" year
2009: Throws Super Bowl losing INT to Saints 26th ranked pass defense. "MVP" year
2010: Throws 1 TD at home in one & done elimination loss to Jets
2012: Turns the ball over 3 times and throws the interception that results in a Ravens field goal to win in 2OT as Broncos exit in the first round.
2013: Loses in the Super Bowl by throwing 2 INTs and being generally unable to move the ball down the field. Game was already lost by the 2nd quarter, in which he got his first 1st down conversion in. Record breaking year.
2014: Throws 1 TD in a blowout loss at home for another one and done against his former team and their subpar defense.
1998 Throws 28 INTs during regular season as team misses playoffs.
1999: Throws 0 TDs in 42 attempts in one & done elimination loss to Titans.
2000: Throws 1 TD in one & done elimination loss to Dolphins, giving them only playoff victory of decade.
2001: Throws 23 INTs during regular season as team misses playoffs.
2002: Throws 0 TDs and 2 INTs in 41-0 one & done elimination loss to the 9-7 Jets.
2003: Throws 4 INTs in AFC Championship game in elimination loss to Patriots. "MVP" year
2004: Throws 0 TDs and 1 INT in AFC Championship game in elimination loss to Patriots. "MVP" year
2005: Throws 1 TD at home in a one & done elimination loss to the Steelers, after a 14-2 season
2006: Throws 3 TDs / 7 INTs with 70.5 QB rating while being carried by his defense and Adam Vinatieri to his only SB.
2007: Throws 6 INTs in reglular season loss to Norv Turner then proceeds to be eliminated in one & done playoff game by same team.
2008: Throws 1 TD against Norv Turner's 31st ranked pass defense in a first round elimination loss to 8-8 Chargers. "MVP" year
2009: Throws Super Bowl losing INT to Saints 26th ranked pass defense. "MVP" year
2010: Throws 1 TD at home in one & done elimination loss to Jets
2012: Turns the ball over 3 times and throws the interception that results in a Ravens field goal to win in 2OT as Broncos exit in the first round.
2013: Loses in the Super Bowl by throwing 2 INTs and being generally unable to move the ball down the field. Game was already lost by the 2nd quarter, in which he got his first 1st down conversion in. Record breaking year.
2014: Throws 1 TD in a blowout loss at home for another one and done against his former team and their subpar defense.
Couldn't agree more.
I know spreads don't matter but it's not like the guy lost 9 times in his 1st game with an inferior team all the time.....he'll I think 6 of those 9 first game losses were at home and I think his teams were favored in 8 or 9 of those games and a td fav in 5 or 6 of those games and dd fav in maybe 3 or 4
He's a regular season fantasy football era stat hound (look at their only td today....a fade from the 1 on 1st down vs running it in)
My personal opinion....the guy is a perfectionist control freak and as the leader of the team, his teams play tight and more afraid to lose when the pressure is on....i think that is reflected in his terrible post season record and dismal td int ratio (in comparison to his regular season marks).....he's a top 10 all time qb, maybe top 5 (not by me) but I wouldn't have him anywhere near the top 10 when it comes to the post season and that is what matters most
Last edited:
