San Francisco/Denver

tulah

Registered User
Forum Member
Sep 10, 2003
3,476
17
38
So Cal
Who Manning ? The greatest ever ? No fucking way.

Manning isnt half the QB MARINO was in his prime.

Geez....I'm old enough to go back to the early 80's NFL.
Marino was a bit more athletic....that's all.
Manning is the smartest QB at the line I've ever witnessed.
He's a magician with his knowledge of defenses.
He's surgical with his accuracy ....
Making guys like Austin collie , Jacob tamme , Anthony Gonzalez , ETC
All look incredible. Till Manning came along Denver considered Thomas a bust.
Lol.

Elway is #2 in my book
Montana
Then Marino
 

Franchise_Davis

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 27, 2005
3,331
7
0
Geez....I'm old enough to go back to the early 80's NFL.
Marino was a bit more athletic....that's all.
Manning is the smartest QB at the line I've ever witnessed.
He's a magician with his knowledge of defenses.
He's surgical with his accuracy ....
Making guys like Austin collie , Jacob tamme , Anthony Gonzalez , ETC
All look incredible. Till Manning came along Denver considered Thomas a bust.
Lol.

Elway is #2 in my book
Montana
Then Marino

I held out as Elway as #1 for a long time, but at this point Peyton has just done too much.
 

Hashish

Smoked
Forum Member
Sep 5, 2006
8,085
107
0
Surf City
Geez....I'm old enough to go back to the early 80's NFL.
Marino was a bit more athletic....that's all.
Manning is the smartest QB at the line I've ever witnessed.
He's a magician with his knowledge of defenses.
He's surgical with his accuracy ....
Making guys like Austin collie , Jacob tamme , Anthony Gonzalez , ETC
All look incredible. Till Manning came along Denver considered Thomas a bust.
Lol.

Elway is #2 in my book
Montana
Then Marino

I agree with all of this. Although older guys tell me Unitas should be in the conversation.

Tfresh, remember that it is better to stay silent and be thought a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt. Disrespecting Manning shows you have no understanding of the game and its history.
 

tulah

Registered User
Forum Member
Sep 10, 2003
3,476
17
38
So Cal
I held out as Elway as #1 for a long time, but at this point Peyton has just done too much.

i agree.
The big negative is He's lost plenty of big games in his career. I can't deny that.

If Manning gets a SB ring this season it would seal it up as the G.O.A.T
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top