Who is a better Quarterback?

Who is a better Quarterback?

  • Peyton Manning

    Votes: 46 90.2%
  • Eli Manning

    Votes: 5 9.8%

  • Total voters
    51
  • Poll closed .

kneifl

Registered User
Forum Member
Jan 12, 2001
9,135
90
0
49
Virginia
www.tradewithjon.com
I want to know. I thought Peyton was better for a while, but the last few years I lean to Eli. What do Madjackers think. Who's the better QB right now?

kneifl
 

AR182

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 9, 2000
18,654
87
0
Scottsdale,AZ
i used to think brady was a better qb, but now imo peyton is one of the top 5 qbs of all time.....he takes charge of the offense like nobody else in the nfl....eli has a long way to go to catch peyton.....
 
MB NCAAF 728x90 Jpg

bleedingpurple

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 23, 2008
22,322
180
63
50
Where it is real F ing COLD
Yeah this one is easy. Peyton does it with virtually no running game and a poor D. ALthough he has tons of talent at WR. Would be interesting to see how they would fair if they traded places.
 

giambi

Registered User
Forum Member
Feb 19, 2003
570
1
0
Las Vegas,NV
if you consider how fast it took them to get rings ........:shrug: ........IMO eli is catching up to big bro but still he got his ring quicker.............. in the words of derek jeter winning is the ONLY thing that matters!!!!
 
MB NCAAF 728x90 Jpg

AR182

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 9, 2000
18,654
87
0
Scottsdale,AZ
if you consider how fast it took them to get rings ........:shrug: ........IMO eli is catching up to big bro but still he got his ring quicker.............. in the words of derek jeter winning is the ONLY thing that matters!!!!

so then you wouldn't consider dan marino or ernie banks great since neither one of them ever won a championship....a lot of it has to do with being in the right place at the right time....ie....bart starr or joe montana....
 

smurphy

cartographer
Channel Member
Jul 31, 2004
19,885
132
63
15
L.A.
so then you wouldn't consider dan marino or ernie banks great since neither one of them ever won a championship....a lot of it has to do with being in the right place at the right time....ie....bart starr or joe montana....

i doubt that is what he saying
 
MB NCAAF 728x90 Jpg

StevieD

Registered User
Forum Member
Jun 18, 2002
9,509
44
48
71
Boston
Before his injury I would give Brady the edge over Peyton. If picking a team today Peyton would be my first choice. Eli is in the top three but needs another year or two of greatness.:shrug:
 
MB NCAAF 728x90 Jpg

gardenweasel

el guapo
Forum Member
Jan 10, 2002
40,552
214
63
"the bunker"
i think you can make the argument that peyton manning is thee single most impactful football player of all time...

certainly the best qb...and it pains me to say it...the colts are horseshit without him...

the only one that i can think of that controls a whole game....that can literally put an entire team on his shoulders to win a game time and agin(ala the miami game)was jim (kufi) brown....brown dominated games...
 
Last edited:

Cie

Registered
Forum Member
Apr 30, 2003
22,391
253
0
New Orleans
if you consider how fast it took them to get rings ........:shrug: ........IMO eli is catching up to big bro but still he got his ring quicker.............. in the words of derek jeter winning is the ONLY thing that matters!!!!

I could not disagree more with your take
 
MB NCAAF 728x90 Jpg

Cie

Registered
Forum Member
Apr 30, 2003
22,391
253
0
New Orleans
One is among the greatest football players of all time, while the other is a good QB (top 10 QB right now imo) with a career rating of 76.1
 

spartan

Registered User
Forum Member
Jan 7, 2001
5,098
37
0
Long Island
I'm a big giant fan but I would take the middle brother over little brother :)
The stature and arm of Peyton puts him ahead but little brother is coming along just fine.
 
MB NCAAF 728x90 Jpg

BUCSnotYUCKS

Registered
Forum Member
Nov 6, 2007
11,839
28
0
39
Ohio but not a Buckeye
Not even close...Eli isn't even top 10 in the league LOL

Peyton, Brees, Brady, Rivers, McNabb, Rogers, Warner are all better without even starting to debate others...(Flacco, Palmer, Roethlisburger, Ryan, Hasselbeck, Favre, and Cutler)
 
Top