Who is the Best Player in Baseball you have ever seen?

AR182

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 9, 2000
18,654
87
0
Scottsdale,AZ
not so sure,bud...the guy was the best leadoff man i ever saw..he was the hub of some very powerful oakland teams for many years..and was on a couple w.s. champions...

he did everything well... all time leader in walks,runs and stolen bases...and he had had excellent power as a leadoff hitter(i believe he retired as a top 100 hiome run hitter,granted more due to longevity...but he still had good power for a smallish guy)....i believe he won a golden glove....he was a guy that the opposing team had to game plan for...you walk him and there was a good chance you just put a man in scoring position...

everybody loves power hitters....but as a complete offensive weapon,i`ve never seen anyone better....and he was extremely durable in his prime....

i think he probably stayed too long...many do...

it`s a subjective opinion...i know i really enjoyed watching him play...

Good post, GW....
 

AR182

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 9, 2000
18,654
87
0
Scottsdale,AZ
Thread states " Who is the Best Player in Base ball you ever SEEN " I grew up in an American League city & the chances of seeing Roberto on TV were far & few except World Series or All Star games. He is on my list but not at the top. How many times did you see Williams play ?

I would have loved to see Williams in his prime....
 

gardenweasel

el guapo
Forum Member
Jan 10, 2002
40,613
255
83
"the bunker"
He was the best right handed pitcher that I have ever seen & Koufax was the best lefty....I would have loved to see them pitch against each other....

i love ya brother...:toast:

we agree on the pitchers....koufax was near unhittable....and gibson was about as intimidating a pitcher as i`ve ever seen(all due deference to nolan ryan and randy johnson)...
 

The Mover

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 22, 2000
3,998
47
0
Detroit,Mi
I would have loved to see Williams in his prime....

Ar... My 1st baseball game 1953 at old Briggs Stadium ( Detroit) I was lucky enough to see the Ted Williams. My father pointed him out to me & said make sure & watch him when he comes up to bat. What great memories... back then you watched games on black & white TV's & then you walk into night game with all those lights & green... green... grass.
 

Old School

OVR
Forum Member
Mar 19, 2006
38,792
636
113
75

rt724

Registered User
Forum Member
Nov 28, 2003
68
3
0
73
down south
wow...didn't realize the head to head record was so strong to Koufax...but my answer was based on who I had seen play in person.

Thanks for the warm replies guys...I'm usually around reading threads but don't follow day to day sports as much anymore as grandkids are very involved in sports year-round.

Just follow my Crimson Tide and Cie and I have a good respect for our programs.

Didn't see them when I followed baseball more closely but always thought Curt Flood and Tony Oliva could handle a bat pretty well.

Free agency and team loyalty tainted my desire to follow many players and teams. Not a slight on any other fans...just an old school thought of mine.

Best to all Madjackers!
 

bleedingpurple

Registered User
Forum Member
Mar 23, 2008
22,494
304
83
52
Where it is real F ing COLD
I will also say a healthy Don Mattingly, man it's too bad that guy got back injuries. He could hit for .350 and hit 30 dongs, yet he would put the ball all over the field going with the pitch. He was an awesome pure hitter.

I went with Rickey cause of what GW posted. Yeah he probably wasn't the best hitter, but I would probably want to build a team around him more than just about any hitter
 
Bet on MyBookie
Top